←back to thread

188 points adrianhon | 10 comments | | HN request time: 1.022s | source | bottom
Show context
galleywest200 ◴[] No.43657406[source]
I have been playing this game and it is really a blast. The tutorial note cards strongly recommend using a pen+paper while playing and I can second that as pretty much required for some of the more "meta" puzzles.

Worth noting that I believe it is also on Gamepass and whatever Sony's version of Gamepass is called if you already had those services and wished to save a few bucks.

replies(3): >>43658125 #>>43659139 #>>43662573 #
1. gs17 ◴[] No.43658125[source]
> The tutorial note cards strongly recommend using a pen+paper while playing

This is my largest complaint. The game should really have a notepad built in. It doesn't need to write down clues for me, but it would be nice to not have to find where my notes were if I put the game down for a long time. Is it that it's a console release?

replies(5): >>43658222 #>>43658356 #>>43659698 #>>43660905 #>>43664499 #
2. RamRodification ◴[] No.43658222[source]
So many games desperately need this feature. Almost all games could benefit from it to some degree. I see zero negative consequences to adding it to every single game in existence just in case someone wants it.
3. detaro ◴[] No.43658356[source]
if you play on PC through Steam, Steam at least has a notes function in the overlay nowadays: https://www.polygon.com/2023/4/28/23702656/steam-beta-update...
replies(2): >>43658629 #>>43660237 #
4. gs17 ◴[] No.43658629[source]
Unfortunately, I'm pretty sure adding Game Pass games to Steam isn't really compatible with that. It looks like there was a "notes" app for the Windows "Game Bar", but it's no longer available.
replies(1): >>43659963 #
5. rjh29 ◴[] No.43659698[source]
I've played 10 hours ish and it needs pen and paper notes. A text notepad probably won't work
6. detaro ◴[] No.43659963{3}[source]
possible, yeah, from what I've heard the launcher is weird for those.
7. Anon1096 ◴[] No.43660237[source]
I don't recommend using it, there's unfortunately a bug where your notes will not save randomly and just disappear between sessions. Which for a note taking feature basically makes it usuable. You can find discussions about the bug on steam ex https://steamcommunity.com/discussions/forum/1/6679490218977...
8. SamBam ◴[] No.43660905[source]
I haven't played this, but I played Obra Dinn, which the review mentions, and I really don't think digital notes would have been nearly as good as pencil and paper. I really needed to draw arrows between things, sketch out a timeline, put question marks around ideas, etc. Pencil and paper is just so much more expressive.
replies(1): >>43662287 #
9. Secretmapper ◴[] No.43662287[source]
I think the option would be great regardless. What you say is true - pen and paper is more expressive than digital notes, but digital notes is better than nothing.

I played Obra Dinn without pen and paper and I was fine.

There was a game called The Roottrees are dead which is based on Obra dinn with a built in journal system and it is really useful.

10. aqme28 ◴[] No.43664499[source]
It’s an indie game. I think that adding a full-fledged note system with as much creativity as paper+pen is a big undertaking and perhaps not the best use of resources for the developer