←back to thread

180 points gnabgib | 5 comments | | HN request time: 0.204s | source
1. basisword ◴[] No.43637969[source]
I know very little about this so excuse me if this is a stupid question. In my country all teenage girls have been getting the vaccine for at least the last 15-20 years. Therefore all of the women I'm likely to sleep with are vaccinated. Does it still make sense as a man to get it?
replies(3): >>43638049 #>>43638121 #>>43638141 #
2. 0cf8612b2e1e ◴[] No.43638049[source]
I guess I am a weirdo, but vaccines are the closest thing we have to space magic. Generally, they are very safe and prevent some of the most devastating diseases. All for the most minor discomfort. I want everything I can get, even if I am unlikely to be exposed to the real infectious agent.
replies(1): >>43638138 #
3. kstrauser ◴[] No.43638121[source]
"All". Even if that's true, some time you might travel and be around women who aren't vaccinated, and you get an infection with something bearing the lovely name "genital warts". It has the long-term complications of "cancer of the cervix, vulva, vagina, penis, anus, mouth, tonsils, or throat". And you can give it to any other women you get with for the next few years, potentially giving them any of those relevant cancers.

So yes. It absolutely makes sense for a man to get it. For selfish reasons, you probably don't want penis cancer. For non-selfish ones, you don't want give other partners cervical cancer.

4. kstrauser ◴[] No.43638138[source]
Same. And while the shingles vaccine isn't fun, I've known enough people who described their bouts with shingles as "nearly suicide inducing" that I'll take a temporary minor discomfort that prevents me from ever having to deal with it.
5. bawolff ◴[] No.43638141[source]
Vaccines aren't 100% effective.

I'm not sure what the effectiveness of the hpv vaccine is, but if it was 95% effective (totally made up number, i dont know what the real one is), then there is a 1 in 20 chance it wont work for someone. If both of you have the vaccine then the chance of both failing would go down to 1 in 400.

That seems worthwhile to me, given there is basically no downside.

(I guess this doesn't account for the affects of herd immunity)