←back to thread

198 points rustoo | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.002s | source
Show context
pdpi ◴[] No.43576908[source]
Fundamentally, rules almost always come with compromises — for the sake of making rules understandable by humans, they have to be relatively simple. Simple rules for complex situations will always forbid some amount of good behaviour, and allow some bad behaviour. Many of society's parasites live in the space of "allowable bad behaviour", but there is a lot of value to knowing how to exploit the "forbidden good behaviour" space.
replies(3): >>43577332 #>>43579928 #>>43581507 #
efavdb ◴[] No.43577332[source]
Example?
replies(5): >>43577376 #>>43578121 #>>43578725 #>>43580392 #>>43583934 #
s1artibartfast ◴[] No.43578121[source]
For which side?

Most examples boil down to common sense. Nobody is going to arrest a 14 year old for driving their dying parent to the hospital.

Similarly, it is reprehensible but legal to pull up a chair and watch a child drown in a pool.

There is a difference between law and morality, and humans will use the second to selectively enforce the former.

replies(2): >>43578792 #>>43578955 #
randomNumber7 ◴[] No.43578792[source]
> Similarly, it is reprehensible but legal to pull up a chair and watch a child drown in a pool.

In which country? Even for the US I don't believe the law system is that crappy.

replies(7): >>43578866 #>>43578882 #>>43578988 #>>43579011 #>>43579905 #>>43584907 #>>43584939 #
1. dragonwriter ◴[] No.43584939{3}[source]
Unless you are the parent, legal guardian, or someone with some other special legal duty to the child where this might be criminal neglect, yes, this is legal in, AFAIK, every US legal jurisdiction — there is no general legal duty to render aid.
replies(1): >>43585319 #
2. randomNumber7 ◴[] No.43585319[source]
In Germany it is different.

- failure to render assistance ("unterlassene Hilfeleistung") up to one year in prison or a fine

- Exposed to a life-threatening situation ("Aussetzung", § 221 StGB) – If a person leaves someone helpless in a life-threatening situation, they could be sentenced to up to 10 years in prison

Edit: Also note that murder would often give you 16 years in germany even though it is called live long.