←back to thread

421 points briankelly | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.305s | source
Show context
necovek ◴[] No.43575664[source]
The premise might possibly be true, but as an actually seasoned Python developer, I've taken a look at one file: https://github.com/dx-tooling/platform-problem-monitoring-co...

All of it smells of a (lousy) junior software engineer: from configuring root logger at the top, module level (which relies on module import caching not to be reapplied), over not using a stdlib config file parser and building one themselves, to a raciness in load_json where it's checked for file existence with an if and then carrying on as if the file is certainly there...

In a nutshell, if the rest of it is like this, it simply sucks.

replies(23): >>43575714 #>>43575764 #>>43575953 #>>43576545 #>>43576732 #>>43576977 #>>43577008 #>>43577017 #>>43577193 #>>43577214 #>>43577226 #>>43577314 #>>43577850 #>>43578934 #>>43578952 #>>43578973 #>>43579760 #>>43581498 #>>43582065 #>>43583922 #>>43585046 #>>43585094 #>>43587376 #
gerdesj ◴[] No.43576977[source]
My current favourite LLM wankery example is this beauty: https://blog.fahadusman.com/proxmox-replacing-failed-drive-i...

Note how it has invented the faster parameter for the zpool command. It is possible that the blog writer hallucinated a faster parameter themselves without needing a LLM - who knows.

I think all developers should add a faster parameter to all commands to make them run faster. Perhaps a LLM could create the faster code.

I predict an increase of man page reading, and better quality documentation at authoritative sources. We will also improve our skills at finding auth sources of docs. My uBlacklist is getting quite long.

replies(2): >>43577304 #>>43579253 #
Henchman21 ◴[] No.43577304[source]
What makes you think this was created by an LLM?

I suspect they might actually have a pool named faster -- I know I've named pools similarly in the past. This is why I now name my pools after characters from the Matrix, as is tradition.

replies(2): >>43577481 #>>43578695 #
lloeki ◴[] No.43578695[source]
The pool is named backups according to zpool status and the paragraph right after.

But then again the old id doesn't match between the two commands.

replies(1): >>43583322 #
1. Henchman21 ◴[] No.43583322[source]
Yep that’s the stuff I noticed that was off too