←back to thread

218 points pseudolus | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.317s | source
Show context
_petronius ◴[] No.43568326[source]
Some art-haters in the comments, so to defend this piece of contemporary art for a moment: one thing I love about it is a commitment to the long future of art, creativity, and civilization. What does it take to keep an instrument playing for six hundred years? To commit to that idea -- like the century-long projects of cathedral building in the middle ages, or the idea of planting trees you won't live to see mature -- is (to me) the awesome thing about the Halberstadt performance. All rendered in a medium (church organ) that has existed for an even longer time.

It's a pretty hopeful, optimistic view of the future in a time of high uncertainty, but also represents a positive argument: it's worth doing these things because they are interesting, weird, and fun, and because they represent a continuity with past and future people we will never meet.

Plus, you can already buy a ticket to the finale, so your distant descendants can go see it :)

replies(11): >>43568467 #>>43568535 #>>43568578 #>>43570159 #>>43572116 #>>43572380 #>>43573148 #>>43574325 #>>43574639 #>>43579149 #>>43591762 #
hbsbsbsndk ◴[] No.43568467[source]
It's not surprising that people who love AI and NFTs are willfully ignorant about what makes art meaningful. It's a sadly transactional view of the world.
replies(6): >>43570652 #>>43572311 #>>43573150 #>>43574210 #>>43574653 #>>43576686 #
mingus88 ◴[] No.43570652[source]
It’s obvious that many people in this industry believe themselves to be supremely intelligent and curious hacker types, yet they obviously never taken a humanities course.

They have a huge blind spot that they aren’t even aware of, or worse just devalue the entire history of human thought and creation that doesn’t involve hard science.

replies(4): >>43572788 #>>43574043 #>>43574822 #>>43575098 #
1. dmoy ◴[] No.43574822[source]
I can appreciate art, and play music at a pretty damn good level myself, but still think that John Cage is totally wack.

I don't dislike all strange music - Satie and Poulenc are some of my favorites. But a lot of John Cage's stuff is... no longer music.

Like I'm sorry, but 4'33" is not music.

I draw a line somewhere, and a lot of John Cage's stuff is wayyyyyyyyy the fuck over the line.

Sure maybe it's some kind of art, but it's not music.