←back to thread

Why is the world losing color?

(www.culture-critic.com)
322 points trevin | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
crazygringo ◴[] No.43558560[source]
It's not "losing" color.

At periods when technology resulted in new color possibilities, people went overboard with color. Make all the things colorful!! Think of the technicolor sixties. And we can go back in history and see the same thing with new clothing pigments, new paint pigments.

But when everything is colorful, nothing stands out. Everything being colorful is as monotonous as everything being, well, monotone.

Modern taste is more about more neutral-colored foundations with color accents. Don't paint a whole room green -- have a gorgeous green plant that stands out all the more against its neutral background. Don't paint a whole wall orange -- have a beautiful orange-hued piece of art on the wall. It's just more tasteful to use color as one element, along with size, shape, texture, and so forth. Making it the main element in everything is just overdoing it. It's bad design.

I don't want constant "riotous color", as the article puts it, in my home, or my workplace, or while I'm driving. It's visually exhausting.

replies(33): >>43558639 #>>43558663 #>>43558702 #>>43558778 #>>43558896 #>>43558911 #>>43559067 #>>43559157 #>>43559220 #>>43559250 #>>43559287 #>>43559328 #>>43559457 #>>43559575 #>>43559624 #>>43559661 #>>43559810 #>>43559852 #>>43560181 #>>43561036 #>>43561732 #>>43562192 #>>43562292 #>>43562538 #>>43562892 #>>43562989 #>>43563047 #>>43563496 #>>43563563 #>>43563946 #>>43565177 #>>43571894 #>>43572804 #
TeMPOraL ◴[] No.43559661[source]
> Modern taste is more about more neutral-colored foundations with color accents. Don't paint a whole room green -- have a gorgeous green plant that stands out all the more against its neutral background. Don't paint a whole wall orange -- have a beautiful orange-hued piece of art on the wall. It's just more tasteful to use color as one element, along with size, shape, texture, and so forth.

I don't consider this to be a be-all, end-all of design, but I appreciate that designs following this approach can be stunningly beautiful. That said, this is not the problem. The problem is, what happens these days, someone films your room with that "gorgeous green plant that stands out all the more against its neutral background" and... color grades the shit out of color, making it near pitch-black on non-HDR TVs (and most computer screens) and merely grey with tiny amounts of trace color on HDR TVs.

This is the problem - or at least its TV aspect. That Napoleon example was spot on - most movies these days look like the right half, whereas anything remotely approaching realism would make it look like the left half. And TFA correctly notices the same washing out of colors is happening to products and spaces in general (which means double trouble when that's filmed and then color-graded some more).

replies(2): >>43559849 #>>43560111 #
crazygringo ◴[] No.43559849[source]
The drained-color thing is exclusive to a certain type of TV/movie drama, and then also a serious technical problem involving HDR device-side (which is a whole other story).

But if you watch any comedy, or reality show, or plenty of "normal" dramas, on a regular TV, the color is normal.

However, yes, there has been a certain trend involving Christopher Nolan, "gritty realism", and legal-political-military-crime themes, to do color grading to massively reduce saturation and aggressively push towards blue. I don't like it much but you can also just not watch that stuff. It's stylistic the same way film noir was. Some people hated that back in the day too, now it's just seen as a style of the time.

replies(2): >>43561076 #>>43563690 #
lupusreal ◴[] No.43563690{3}[source]
> The drained-color thing is exclusive to a certain type of TV/movie drama

You're absolutely wrong, it happened to video games too. The industry defended it by saying it made games look more "realistic", but have since backed off after consumers revolted and dubbed the aesthetic "piss filter."

Started in the mid 00s, went strong for about a decade and still persists to a lesser degree today. Only designers like it, consumers broadly hate it.

replies(1): >>43568685 #
1. crazygringo ◴[] No.43568685{4}[source]
I meant a certain type within TV/movies. As opposed to other types of TV/movies.

I can't speak to video games, but of course it would make sense it would apply to dramatic video games as well.