←back to thread

295 points mdhb | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.609s | source
Show context
bsimpson ◴[] No.43560742[source]

One nice side effect of Signal's importance for governmental/military use is that it helps keep it free for civilian use. They can't mandate a backdoor for something other parts of the government rely on to be secure.

I once heard a great anecdote to that effect, and to my embarrassment I can't recall the details to repeat here.

(And yes, I understand that there are limits on what is appropriate to share with civilian hardware on a civilian network, but the truth stands that part of the reason there's not a push to breach encryption in the US like there is in the UK is because Signal is relied upon even by the government when they need a private channel on civilian hardware.)

replies(9): >>43560773 #>>43560780 #>>43560782 #>>43560939 #>>43560995 #>>43561150 #>>43561233 #>>43561254 #>>43561325 #
kelipso ◴[] No.43560782[source]

> They can't mandate a backdoor for something other parts of the government rely on to be secure.

This is a strong assumption.. A government is a collection of people. While there might not exactly be warring factions in the US government, there are certainly numerous agencies and organizations that operate under varying degrees of independence.

replies(2): >>43561272 #>>43561339 #
1. walterbell ◴[] No.43561272[source]

News reports would be much clearer if each faction had a medieval crest, logo, or even UUID.

replies(1): >>43561575 #
2. Yoric ◴[] No.43561575[source]

Give them a NFT.