←back to thread

110 points PaulHoule | 5 comments | | HN request time: 0.621s | source
Show context
karim79 ◴[] No.43552251[source]
I truly hope that the common theme of the likes of "JWST Just Found Something Which Should Not Exist" etc will not be augmented by stuff like "we used AI(tm) to figure out X, Y, Z".

The last thing we need is hallucinations fucking up the more grounded astrophysics. I'm not saying that is what is happening, I just worry about stuff like this. AI causing us to bark up the wrong tree, and so forth.

replies(6): >>43552334 #>>43552343 #>>43552572 #>>43553400 #>>43554487 #>>43556476 #
1. Kye ◴[] No.43552343[source]
Machine learning (AI) is used everywhere in astronomy. That's how they made the black hole image. Don't confuse the broader 60+ year old world of ML with transformers and diffusion models.
replies(2): >>43552413 #>>43552650 #
2. vlovich123 ◴[] No.43552413[source]
Based on the paper I linked, it seems like a straight up classical sampling and clustering with baysian hyperparameter tuning. This is “everything is now AI” slop that’s infected all grants, academic and private industry fundraising. There’s no neural net or LLM involved.
replies(1): >>43552447 #
3. refulgentis ◴[] No.43552447[source]
That's machine learning.

Clustering alone is machine learning and has been taught as such to innumerable people.

I have deep feelings about this, someone in management taking exactly one Kaggle course managed to wield this knowledge to great damage.

But it is machine learning.

Additionally, it goes far beyond clustering: the article you linked describes training an image recognition model, which also seems to be heavily stressed in the article linked on HN.

4. cma ◴[] No.43552650[source]
Not sure if there was an update/response to this but:

     1st image of our Milky Way's black hole may be inaccurate, scientists say
https://www.space.com/the-universe/black-holes/1st-image-of-...
replies(1): >>43552757 #
5. Kye ◴[] No.43552757[source]
It looks like the disagreement is over the exact shape with new technology on the way to help figure it out.

For another ML-assisted science thing, there's the LHC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_boson#Findings_since_201...