←back to thread

423 points serjester | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.214s | source
Show context
danso ◴[] No.43537299[source]
I think the replies [0] to the mentioned reddit thread sums up my (perhaps complacent?) feelings about the current state of automated AI programming:

> Does it terrify anyone else that there is an entire cohort of new engineers who are getting into programming because of AI, but missing these absolute basic bare necessities?

> > Terrify? No, it's reassuring that I might still have a place in the world.

[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/cursor/comments/1inoryp/comment/mdo...

replies(1): >>43537492 #
bob1029 ◴[] No.43537492[source]
The reddit post feels like engagement bait to me.

Why would you ask the community a question like "how to source control" when you've been working with (presumably) a programming genius LLM that could provide the most personally tailored path for baby's first git experience? Even if you don't know that "git" is a thing, you could ask questions as if you were a golden retriever and the model would still inevitably recommend git in the first turn of conversation.

Is it really the case that a person who has the ability to use a compiler, IDE, LLM, web browser, reddit, etc., somehow simultaneously lacks the ability to frame basic-ass questions about the very mission they set out on? If stuff like this is not manufactured, then we should all walk away feeling pretty fantastic about our future job prospects.

replies(3): >>43537572 #>>43537584 #>>43538015 #
1. danso ◴[] No.43537572[source]
The account is a throwaway but based on its short posting history and its replies, I don't have reason to believe it's a troll:

https://www.reddit.com/r/cursor/comments/1inoryp/comment/mdr...

> I'm not a dev or engineers at all (just a geek working in Finance)

This fits my experience of teaching very intelligent students how to code; if you're an experienced programmer, you simply cannot fathom the kinds of assumptions beginners will make due to gaps in yet-to-be foundational knowledge. I remember having to tell students to mindful when searching Stack Overflow for help, because of how something as simple as an error from Requests (e.g. while doing web scraping) could lead them down a rabbit hole of "solutions" such as completely uninstalling their Python for a different/older version of Python.