←back to thread

1192 points gniting | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.257s | source
Show context
photonthug ◴[] No.43521952[source]
> It's worth acknowledging that there are some legitimate reasons for an app to check which other apps are installed on your phone. For example, an app might check which UPI apps are installed to show relevant payment options.

Nope! Nope, nope, nope. If you're wondering how we got into this situation.. well, it's exactly stuff like this. Weird to see someone who's digging into it at all also making excuses for it.

No one ever said "I want to avoid a single extra click once every other month, so I guess I better irrevocably open my data/phone/life up completely to megacorp forever". And they certainly did not say this about tinycorp. People just absolutely suck at adversarial thinking, and good guys need to do it for them before bad guys can. Do you want organized crime blackmailing your politicians about dating apps and infidelity? Do you want to make it easy to do large scale targeting of ${vulnerable_people} the next time the cultural or political climate shifts?

Come on. Anyway shouldn't the phone OS itself handle this rather than apps launching apps?? If not.. just let people pick a payment option, and then throw an error if the option is not available.

replies(2): >>43522078 #>>43533275 #
qwe----3 ◴[] No.43522078[source]
> "I want to avoid a single extra click once every other month, so I guess I better irrevocably open my data/phone/life up completely to megacorp forever"

Nah, it's super annoying when I click on a link and don't get redirected to the native app. This happens way more then once a month. Web experiences are much worse for many things.

replies(2): >>43522211 #>>43522980 #
1. photonthug ◴[] No.43522211[source]
Cool but the attitude of “bring on the dystopian future as long as it’s more convenient for some people some of the time” is still confusing to me. Do you imagine that leaked information like this has never gotten someone killed before, and never will in the future?