←back to thread

Waymos crash less than human drivers

(www.understandingai.org)
345 points rbanffy | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
labrador ◴[] No.43487628[source]
I was initially skeptical about self-driving cars but I've been won over by Waymo's careful and thoughtful approach using visual cues, lidar, safety drivers and geo-fencing. That said I will never trust my life to a Tesla robotaxi that uses visual cues only and will drive into a wall painted to look like the road ahead like Wile E. Coyote. Beep beep.

Man Tests If Tesla Autopilot Will Crash Into Wall Painted to Look Like Road https://futurism.com/tesla-wall-autopilot

replies(7): >>43487811 #>>43488043 #>>43490629 #>>43490938 #>>43490978 #>>43491005 #>>43511057 #
Ferret7446 ◴[] No.43491005[source]
A wall painted to look like a road would likely cause human accidents and the painter would be very much criminally liable for them.

That said, I do think using only visual cues is a stupid self-imposed restriction. We shouldn't be making self-driving cars like humans, because humans suck horse testicles at driving.

replies(3): >>43491335 #>>43491665 #>>43493832 #
timewizard ◴[] No.43491335[source]
> because humans suck horse testicles at driving.

Hardly. We drive hundreds of billions of miles every month and trillions every year. In the US alone. You're more likely to die from each of the flu, diabetes or a stroke than a car accident.

If those don't get you, you are either going to get heart disease or cancer, or most likely, involve yourself in a fatal accident; which, will most likely be a fall of a roof or a ladder.

replies(3): >>43491421 #>>43491732 #>>43492190 #
michaelt ◴[] No.43491421[source]
Is 40,000 deaths every year a lot?

IMHO it kinda is. It's 13x as many people as died in 9/11

replies(2): >>43491781 #>>43491955 #
timewizard ◴[] No.43491781[source]
> Is 40,000 deaths every year a lot?

No. It's 1.25 per 10,000 per capita. Most people understand the risk ahead of time and yet still choose to drive. They clearly don't think it is.

> It's 13x as many people as died in 9/11

And 50x 9/11 many people die of accidental self inflicted injury. This is an absurd metric.

replies(3): >>43492116 #>>43492338 #>>43493855 #
Peanuts99 ◴[] No.43492116{5}[source]
The US car fatalities per mile is double than the UK. It would at least be useful to ask why that might be. That's 40,000 people a year who have their lives cut short.
replies(2): >>43492674 #>>43497218 #
1. Qwertious ◴[] No.43492674{6}[source]
It's street design. If you prioritize car throughput at any cost, even safety, then your streets will be less safe.