←back to thread

312 points campuscodi | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.251s | source
Show context
tptacek ◴[] No.43375191[source]
SAML (more broadly XML-DSIG) is literally the worst security protocol in common use. I think you should generally be taking whatever hits you need to take to transition from it to OAuth. Certainly, I would refuse to bring a new product to market that relied on it. It's incredibly dangerous. Unless there's some breakthrough in practical formal verification, I can't imagine that this will be the last or the worst DSIG vulnerability.
replies(4): >>43375239 #>>43375862 #>>43376397 #>>43376552 #
nimish ◴[] No.43375862[source]
One day I will write an essay on all of the incredibly stupid things XML DSig does, and that's not even touching the cryptography. It's peak enterprise software brain.

Someone should go deep on the mailing list and standards body horrors of WS-* and OASIS/XACML and all that crap

replies(1): >>43380286 #
1. pushkar2911 ◴[] No.43380286[source]
Please write about this. I would love to read it.