←back to thread

324 points dvh | 9 comments | | HN request time: 0.499s | source | bottom
1. Timshel ◴[] No.43298517[source]
How is it still at 4.6 stars ??? On Firefox it dropped to 2.9 ...
replies(4): >>43298529 #>>43298550 #>>43298634 #>>43300864 #
2. dvh ◴[] No.43298529[source]
They are probably using median
3. nomilk ◴[] No.43298550[source]
Lots of bad apps on Apple App Store also have surprisingly high average ratings.

My best guess: the app asks the user whether they're enjoying it, if yes, asks for a review, if no, nothing.

replies(3): >>43298734 #>>43299388 #>>43300219 #
4. hicallmeal ◴[] No.43298634[source]
In addition to a sibling comment about median, it could be that or that other common method (I forget, bayesion average? I think), but also consider - 176K reviews, 76 days since the _expose_, if it were 100 reviews a day on average, that's still 7.6K reviews. If it were 10K in the first few days, then 7.6K after, it's still ~10% of total reviews, where they likely had a ~4.6-8 score before hand. A drop in the bucket.

And it's possible (though imo unlikely) that some reviews were removed, perhaps initially at least, due to suspected botting.

replies(1): >>43299250 #
5. sebazzz ◴[] No.43298734[source]
Om the other hand, negative experiences would lead to a review earlier. You know, the loud negative majority.
6. manquer ◴[] No.43299250[source]
Median has little difference to mean when it is a bounded variable .

Rating can only vary 1-5, so mean and median will always be pretty close . For variables like say wealth that skews the average with outliers is where median is more useful than mean

7. braiamp ◴[] No.43299388[source]
Firefox users are more informed and militant in how to make an effective evaluation on the site. Chrome users are governed by lowest common denominator.
8. klausa ◴[] No.43300219[source]
This has been disallowed on the App Store for a couple of years now; but of course is completely unenforced.
9. b0ner_t0ner ◴[] No.43300864[source]
Google doesn't do a very good job of moderating or removing fake ratings, I mean, look at Microsoft's apps on Google Play, look at all those 4.5+ ratings:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/dev?id=672084787255366272...