←back to thread

371 points ulrischa | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.251s | source
Show context
notepad0x90 ◴[] No.43236385[source]
My fear is that LLM generated code will look great to me, I won't understand it fully but it will work. But since I didn't author it, I wouldn't be great at finding bugs in it or logical flaws. Especially if you consider coding as piecing together things instead of implementing a well designed plan. Lots of pieces making up the whole picture but a lot of those pieces are now put there by an algorithm making educated guesses.

Perhaps I'm just not that great of a coder, but I do have lots of code where if someone took a look it, it might look crazy but it really is the best solution I could find. I'm concerned LLMs won't do that, they won't take risks a human would or understand the implications of a block of code beyond its application in that specific context.

Other times, I feel like I'm pretty good at figuring out things and struggling in a time-efficient manner before arriving at a solution. LLM generated code is neat but I still have to spend similar amounts of time, except now I'm doing more QA and clean up work instead of debugging and figuring out new solutions, which isn't fun at all.

replies(13): >>43236847 #>>43237043 #>>43237101 #>>43237162 #>>43237387 #>>43237808 #>>43237956 #>>43238722 #>>43238763 #>>43238978 #>>43239372 #>>43239665 #>>43241112 #
1. intended ◴[] No.43238763[source]
I think this is a great line: > My fear is that LLM generated code will look great to me, I won't understand it fully but it will work

This is a degree of humility that made the scenario we are in much clearer.

Our information environment got polluted by the lack of such humility. Rhetoric that sounded ‘right’ is used everywhere. If it looks like an Oxford Don, sounds like an Oxford Don, then it must be an academic. Thus it is believable, even if they are saying the Titanic isn’t sinking.

Verification is the heart of everything humanity does, our governance structures, our judicial systems, economic systems, academia, news, media - everything.

It’s a massive computation effort to figure out what the best ways to allocate resources given current information, allowing humans to create surplus and survive.

This is why we dislike monopolies, or manipulations of these markets - they create bad goods, and screw up our ability to verify what is real.