←back to thread

641 points shortformblog | 6 comments | | HN request time: 1.047s | source | bottom
Show context
lxgr ◴[] No.42950057[source]
Old movies have been available on various "free ad-supported streaming television" for a while now, so I'm actually more surprised it took copyright holders that long to realize that Youtube also shows ads and doesn't require people to install some wonky app that might or might not be available for their platform.

Of course, region-specific copyright deals are incredibly complex etc. etc., so I could imagine it was just a matter of waiting out until the last person putting up a veto retired or moved on to other things.

replies(12): >>42950694 #>>42950872 #>>42950880 #>>42951141 #>>42951145 #>>42951447 #>>42951871 #>>42952649 #>>42956486 #>>42956621 #>>42960083 #>>42962040 #
SteveNuts ◴[] No.42950694[source]
I assume that bandwidth is by far the biggest cost for running your own streaming service, so letting Google take that hit makes a lot of sense.
replies(12): >>42950809 #>>42950826 #>>42950879 #>>42951020 #>>42951166 #>>42952128 #>>42953063 #>>42953304 #>>42954303 #>>42957205 #>>42964930 #>>42965743 #
TuringNYC ◴[] No.42953063[source]
>> I assume that bandwidth is by far the biggest cost for running your own streaming service, so letting Google take that hit makes a lot of sense.

Judging from the clunky, buggy, nonsensical experiences on 2nd tier streaming services (i.e., everything except Netflix, Amazon Prime, YouTube, Disney+, Max), I'd say the biggest cost is probably hiring a decent Engineering+Product+Test team. There are complexities here, like making these things work on different TV brands, versions, older models, etc.

Pushing all the complexity to YT seems like a total no-brainer.

replies(9): >>42953291 #>>42953557 #>>42958927 #>>42959986 #>>42961969 #>>42965417 #>>42965563 #>>42965935 #>>42970104 #
jmholla ◴[] No.42953291[source]
> Judging from the clunky, buggy, nonsensical experiences on 2nd tier streaming services (i.e., everything except Netflix, Amazon Prime, YouTube, Disney+, Max)

With the exception of Netflix, these other companies' apps are similarly buggy and painful to use. I run into an at least issue daily (usually multiple times a day) in every streaming app I use except Netflix.

replies(9): >>42953384 #>>42953820 #>>42954635 #>>42955062 #>>42955100 #>>42957232 #>>42960229 #>>42960682 #>>42961988 #
jampekka ◴[] No.42954635[source]
Gotta love how streaming torrents through shady debrid and indexing services with Stremio is a smoother experience than what these megacorporations with massive budgets manage to scrape together.
replies(1): >>42962205 #
1. flkenosad ◴[] No.42962205[source]
Shout out to all the devs who never sold their souls.
replies(1): >>42962440 #
2. 1oooqooq ◴[] No.42962440[source]
except all those "consumer friedly" torrent things are the definition of selling one's soul.
replies(1): >>42962565 #
3. jampekka ◴[] No.42962565[source]
In what sense? Leeching?
replies(1): >>42963528 #
4. 1oooqooq ◴[] No.42963528{3}[source]
most of the clients are ripped off open source and sold for profit/subscription. and filled to the brim with trojans and adware.
replies(2): >>42963995 #>>42966736 #
5. hedora ◴[] No.42963995{4}[source]
Isn’t that the same as 99% of commercial phone apps?

(Not defending it; I’m just saying it compares favorably with whatever crap is in most non-pirate apps.)

6. jampekka ◴[] No.42966736{4}[source]
Stremio is (mostly) open source and doesn't cost a penny and AFAIK has no malware. It does sometimes have some ads, about which they are very open about.

Debrid and torrent indexing services are simple websites/APIs with some mostly proprietary hacked together backends. Some of them have subscriptions, but you know what you buy if you subscribe, and many don't even have recurring payments. Someone probably makes some profit out of those, but I'd guess the margins are quite slim, and there's a lot of competition.

There are surely a lot of scams out there too, but I'm quite well aware what my $3 per month buys and I know better what I'm installing or downloading than with any commercial services.

Majority of what's happening underneath is done by the saints of the scene, taking huge risks for zero pay.