←back to thread

1343 points Hold-And-Modify | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source

Hello.

Cloudflare's Browser Intergrity Check/Verification/Challenge feature used by many websites, is denying access to users of non-mainstream browsers like Pale Moon.

Users reports began on January 31:

https://forum.palemoon.org/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=32045

This situation occurs at least once a year, and there is no easy way to contact Cloudflare. Their "Submit feedback" tool yields no results. A Cloudflare Community topic was flagged as "spam" by members of that community and was promptly locked with no real solution, and no official response from Cloudflare:

https://community.cloudflare.com/t/access-denied-to-pale-moo...

Partial list of other browsers that are being denied access:

Falkon, SeaMonkey, IceCat, Basilisk.

Hacker News 2022 post about the same issue, which brought attention and had Cloudflare quickly patching the issue:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31317886

A Cloudflare product manager declared back then: "...we do not want to be in the business of saying one browser is more legitimate than another."

As of now, there is no official response from Cloudflare. Internet access is still denied by their tool.

Show context
windsignaling ◴[] No.42955454[source]
As a website owner and VPN user I see both sides of this.

On one hand, I get the annoying "Verify" box every time I use ChatGPT (and now due its popularity, DeepSeek as well).

On the other hand, without Cloudflare I'd be seeing thousands of junk requests and hacking attempts everyday, people attempting credit card fraud, etc.

I honestly don't know what the solution is.

replies(15): >>42955722 #>>42955733 #>>42956022 #>>42956059 #>>42956088 #>>42956502 #>>42957016 #>>42957235 #>>42959074 #>>42959436 #>>42959515 #>>42959590 #>>42963545 #>>42963562 #>>42966987 #
gjsman-1000 ◴[] No.42955722[source]
Simple: We need to acknowledge that the vision of a decentralized internet as it was implemented was a complete failure, is dying, and will probably never return.

Robots went out of control, whether malicious or the AI scrapers or the Clearview surveillance kind; users learned to not trust random websites; SEO spam ruined search, the only thing that made a decentralized internet navigable; nation state attacks became a common occurrence; people prefer a few websites that do everything (Facebook becoming an eBay competitor). Even if it were possible to set rules banning Clearview or AI training, no nation outside of your own will follow them; an issue which even becomes a national security problem (are you sure, Taiwan, that China hasn't profiled everyone on your social media platforms by now?)

There is no solution. The dream itself was not sustainable. The only solution is either a global moratorium of understanding which everyone respectfully follows (wishful thinking, never happening); or splinternetting into national internets with different rules and strong firewalls (which is a deal with the devil, and still admitting the vision failed).

replies(4): >>42956285 #>>42956514 #>>42956574 #>>42956590 #
Aeolun ◴[] No.42956514[source]
The great firewall, but in reverse.
replies(1): >>42956566 #
gjsman-1000 ◴[] No.42956566{3}[source]
What other choice do we have?

Countries, whether it be Ukraine or Taiwan, can't risk other countries harvesting their social media platforms for the mother of all purges. I never assume that anything that happened historically can never happen again - no Polish Jew would have survived the Nazis with this kind of information theft. Add AI into the mix, and wiping out any population is as easy as baking pie.

Countries are tired of bad behavior. Just ask my grandmother, who has had her designs stolen and mass produced from China. Not just companies - many free and open source companies cannot survive with such reckless competition. Can Prusa survive a world where China takes, but never gives? How many grandmothers does it take being scammed? How many educational systems containing data on minors need to be stolen? The MPAA and RIAA has been whining for years about the copyright problem, and while we laugh at them, never underestimate them. The list goes on and on.

Startups are tired of paying Cloudflare or AWS protection money, and trying to evade the endless sea of SEO spam. How can a startup compete with Google with so much trash and no recourse? Who can build a new web browser, and be widely accepted as being a friendly visitor? Who can build a new social media platform, without the experience and scale to know who is friend or foe?

Now we have AI, gasoline and soon to be dynamite on the fire. For the first time ever, a malicious country can VPN into the internet of a friendly nation, track down all critics on their social media, and destroy their lives in a real world attack (physical or virtual). We are only beginning to see this in Ukraine - are we delusional enough to believe that the world is past warfare? For the first time, anyone in the world could make nudes of women and share them online, from a location where they'll probably never be taken down. If a Russian company offered nudes as a service to American customers with cryptocurrency payments and a slick website that went viral, do you think tolerance is a winning political position?

replies(2): >>42958831 #>>42960760 #
1. rat87 ◴[] No.42958831{4}[source]
> no Polish Jew would have survived the Nazis with this kind of information theft.

I'm not sure this is a good is a good example. I believe a majority of Polish Jewish survivors were those who fled into parts of soviet union not occupied by nazis(some were sent to gulags but this was still much better chance to survive then those who stayed in Poland). Another large portion were in concentration camps and hadn't been killed yet. And I believe 60,000 or less are estimated to have hid in Poland through the war. It's unlikely many remained in their pre war identities and simply concealed their Jewishness and managed to survive.