←back to thread

617 points jbegley | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.208s | source
Show context
tmnvdb ◴[] No.42940589[source]
Good, this idea that all weapons are evil is an insane luxury belief.
replies(10): >>42940656 #>>42940666 #>>42940969 #>>42940977 #>>42941357 #>>42941474 #>>42941623 #>>42941755 #>>42941872 #>>42944147 #
1. PessimalDecimal ◴[] No.42944147[source]
You're either misdirecting the discussion, or have missed the point. The statement isn't about weapons, but the means of _control_ of weapons.

It's legitimate to worry about scaled, automated control of weapons, since it could allow a very small number of people to harm a much larger number of people. That removes one of our best checks we have against the misuse of weaponry. If you have to muster a whole army to go kill a bunch of people, they can collectively revolt. (It's not always _easy_ but it's possible.)

Automating weapons is a lot like nuclear weapons in some ways. Once the hard parts are done (refining raw oar), the ability for a small number of people to harm a vast number of others is serious. People are right to worry about it.