←back to thread

927 points smallerfish | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
dhosek ◴[] No.42927933[source]
Structurally, Bitcoin is a lousy idea for a currency as it is intrinsically deflationary (i.e., even without the speculative inflating of the cost of a Bitcoin, the structure of the coin is such that coins become increasingly scarce and expensive as time goes by). You do not want this in your currency. The ideal is a low-level of inflation which provides an incentive to spend sooner rather than later. With a deflationary currency, the incentive is to put off purchases as long as possible as your currency will buy more tomorrow than it does today. Deflation ends up being economically disastrous, as Japan’s battles with deflation over most of the twenty-first century have shown.

This is why, aside from speculation, purchase of illicit goods and ransom payments, Bitcoin has had little traction as a currency.

replies(4): >>42927999 #>>42928175 #>>42928455 #>>42930480 #
aboardRat4 ◴[] No.42928175[source]
>You do not want this in your currency.

I really want this in my currency.

Bitcoin might be a Ponzi scheme, but fiat currencies are even more so.

replies(2): >>42928204 #>>42928407 #
1. creato ◴[] No.42928407[source]
> I really want this in my currency.

A deflationary currency that you own a disproportionate amount of is great. For you.

replies(2): >>42928536 #>>42941353 #
2. not_really ◴[] No.42928536[source]
did the person you are responding to say that he owns a lot of a given currency? How do you know?
3. aboardRat4 ◴[] No.42941353[source]
Quite the opposite.

If you own a disproportionate amount of INflationary currency, you are, you know, still a rich person who can afford investments, investment consultants, tax optimization experts, have preferential treatment from banks and personal relations with the government employees, so you're good anyway.

Whereas if you're poor, you don't even have a chance to save enough to invest a little bit, because whatever you save today becomes useless paper tomorrow, so you're forced to spend, thus enriching service and goods providers, that is the rich.

In a deflationary currency you actually have a chance to save some money for an investment, plan for tomorrow, or even next year, and not spend everything today while money still have today's value.