←back to thread

El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender

(ticotimes.net)
927 points smallerfish | 1 comments | 04 Feb 25 00:00 UTC | HN request time: 0.366s | source
Show context
ggm ◴[04 Feb 25 00:12 UTC] No.42925329[source]▶
Speculative asset class fails as non-speculative legal tender class.

If king for the day with a sovereign wealth fund I wouldn't forbid investment choices like this on risk grounds, I mean you need risk assets as well as boring ones, right? But I have problems with the moral quality: it's like state investing in the casino business. Monaco? works fine. Anywhere else? It's got problems.

Like a lot of people, I probably fall into severe errors which would be bread and butter for "bad economics" reddit groups but truly, I can't see how this wasn't forseen and expected. It was about WHEN, not IF.

replies(5): >>42925821 #>>42926053 #>>42926355 #>>42926561 #>>42926664 #
codethief ◴[04 Feb 25 01:39 UTC] No.42926355[source]▶
> Speculative asset class fails as non-speculative legal tender class.

This. Bitcoin proponents often claim that eventually everyone will use Bitcoin for payments ("Finally no more governments or central banks!") and that's why it will increase in value, so everyone should invest in BTC.

But this argument is fundamentally flawed: A currency, in order for it to work (in order for people to be able to trust it), needs to be stable in value. Which contradicts it being an investment vehicle and drastically varying in value over time.

replies(6): >>42926450 #>>42926575 #>>42926687 #>>42926867 #>>42927176 #>>42927942 #
aydyn ◴[04 Feb 25 02:24 UTC] No.42926867[source]▶
What currency is stable in value? Certainly not the U.S. dollar.
replies(5): >>42926933 #>>42927043 #>>42927173 #>>42927350 #>>42928400 #
mystified5016 ◴[04 Feb 25 02:44 UTC] No.42927043[source]▶
The USD doesn't frequently lose all or nearly all value as we see from cryptocoins. My $10 today will be worth $10 tomorrow barring nuclear war or an apocalypse.
replies(3): >>42927216 #>>42927339 #>>42928346 #
1. FabHK ◴[04 Feb 25 03:00 UTC] No.42927216[source]▶
And anything beyond 3m you put into real estate, stocks, or bonds anyway. Real rates have mostly been positive; and if not, that's the result of an economy wide equilibrium process that can't be undone risklessly by some magic beans.