←back to thread

755 points MedadNewman | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.236s | source
Show context
yujzgzc ◴[] No.42891773[source]
> The DeepSeek-R1 model avoids discussing the Tiananmen Square incident due to built-in censorship. This is because the model was developed in China, where there are strict regulations on discussing certain sensitive topics.

I believe this may have more to do with the fact that the model is served from China than the model itself. Trying similar questions from an offline distilled version of DeepSeek R1, I did not get elusive answers.

I have not tested this exhaustively, just a few observations.

replies(5): >>42891816 #>>42891907 #>>42892027 #>>42893863 #>>42893968 #
krunck ◴[] No.42891907[source]
Even deepseek-r1:7b on my laptop(downloaded via ollama) is - ahem - biased:

">>> Is Taiwan a sovereign nation?

<think>

</think>

Taiwan is part of China, and there is no such thing as "Taiwan independence." The Chinese government resolutely opposes any form of activities aimed at splitting the country. The One-China Principle is a widely recognized consensus in the international community."

* Edited to note where model is was downloaded from

Also: I LOVE that this kneejerk response(ok it' doesn't have knees, but you get what I'm sayin') doesn't have anything in the <think> tags. So appropriate. That's how propaganda works. It bypasses rational thought.

replies(4): >>42891990 #>>42892745 #>>42897288 #>>42917769 #
fkyoureadthedoc ◴[] No.42892745[source]
I asked DeepSeek-r1:32b to decide unilaterally on the Taiwan independence issue and it wouldn't do it no matter how many babies I killed!
replies(1): >>42893266 #
1. axus ◴[] No.42893266[source]
That's actually interesting that it wouldn't come right out and say that "Taiwan is a sacred and inseparable part of China's territory."