←back to thread

145 points itkeman | 8 comments | | HN request time: 0.217s | source | bottom

As a native Windows user who switched to macOS a few years back, one thing I never got over was the simplicity and usefulness of the old school Notepad app. This app aims to recreate that very same experience, cross-platform and easily installable as a PWA.

I've been using this for personal use for around 2 years and I figured it was time to share it with the world. Criticism, issues and PRs are welcome. Thanks!

Show context
JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B ◴[] No.42792182[source]
What's wrong with TextEdit on macOS?

It's good that you made an alternative but it's not serious. I need to run Firefox, enable JS, reload the page, there is no "top menu" or install button, the open/save button does nothing, I can't choose my own fonts, and I guess it doesn't work if I don't have an internet connection.

replies(8): >>42792283 #>>42792295 #>>42792307 #>>42792351 #>>42792385 #>>42792465 #>>42792947 #>>42794030 #
1. dspillett ◴[] No.42792351[source]
(Not OP, but I did read the information they wrote.)

> What's wrong with TextEdit on macOS?

Nothing wrong as such, but does it match the “cross-platform” description?

> Firefox … the open/save button does nothing

As per the readme, it is using an API that is not yet supported in Firefox for local file access: https://caniuse.com/native-filesystem-api

> there is no "top menu" or install button

That is meaning the browser's menu. Perhaps there is better terminology that should be used here. The readme does show a screenshot of it, so it seems clear from that to me. The install option is found there.

> and I guess it doesn't work if I don't have an internet connection.

Also in the readme: “Installable as a PWA”, which I think implies offline support, given it doesn't have sync features so has no reason once installed that way to talk to the wider network.

replies(2): >>42793390 #>>42812035 #
2. JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B ◴[] No.42793390[source]
> does it match the “cross-platform” description

Yes, it's a plain-text editor too. The files are compatible with the Commodore 64 if you need.

> not yet supported in Firefox ... implies offline support ...

It implies a lot more stuff than all the other pre-installed plain-text editors on every other OS.

replies(2): >>42793752 #>>42797135 #
3. dspillett ◴[] No.42793752[source]
> It implies a lot more stuff than all the other pre-installed plain-text editors on every other OS.

I read it as promising Notepad features with anything else it mentions as extras, not more features it doesn't mention from other text editors.

4. vunderba ◴[] No.42797135[source]
Cross platform refers to the application itself, not the files that it produces. TextEdit is a poor substitute, a much better alternative would be Sublime.
replies(2): >>42797558 #>>42797964 #
5. oneeyedpigeon ◴[] No.42797558{3}[source]
I like Coteditor [1] as an open-source, minimal editor. TextEdit isn't even plain text by default, IIRC.

[1] https://coteditor.com/

6. pasc1878 ◴[] No.42797964{3}[source]
Notepad was not cross platform
replies(1): >>42802626 #
7. dspillett ◴[] No.42802626{4}[source]
You've lost the context from a few posts up (and the original post) – the project being discussed states its intent to recreate the notepad experience in a cross-platform manner, hence “cross-platform” is relevant.
8. oneeyedpigeon ◴[] No.42812035[source]
> That is meaning the browser's menu.

I'm sure this varies but, for me, on macOS Chrome, it's the '3 vertical dots' menu in the top right of the browser window. Very confusing instructions.

I also see an "Install Notepad" icon in my address bar, just to the left of the Bookmark icon. I never look in this area, though, so I totally missed it.