←back to thread

223 points benkaiser | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source | bottom
Show context
ddtaylor ◴[] No.42538247[source]
I'm heavily biased here because I don't find much value in the bible personally. Some of the stories are interesting and some interpretations seem useful, but as a whole I find it arbitrary.

I never tell other people what to believe or how they should do that in any capacity.

With that said I find the hallucination component here fascinating. From my perspective everyone who interprets various religious text does so differently and usually that involves varying levels of fabrication or something that looks a lot like it. I'm speaking about the "talking in tongues" and other methods here. I'm not trying to lump all religions into the same bag here, but I have seen that a lot have different ways of "receiving" communication or directive. To me this seems pretty consistent with the colloquial idea of a hallucination.

replies(4): >>42538376 #>>42542763 #>>42543462 #>>42545126 #
hackernewds ◴[] No.42538376[source]
A really long word salad that doesn't say much, except state your religious pinions and disclaimer? It really is not necessary

With that said, all you said is that the process of transmitting religious ideas is akin to hallucination? Care to explain what the logical argument for that is?

replies(1): >>42539239 #
1. ddtaylor ◴[] No.42539239[source]
That's not accurate. I think my post articulates clearly my thoughts. Happy holidays.
replies(2): >>42542574 #>>42542647 #
2. joemazerino ◴[] No.42542574[source]
It's Merry Christmas.
replies(2): >>42543116 #>>42546939 #
3. marky1991 ◴[] No.42542647[source]
I honestly got the same impression as the other guy, so if there was something else there intended, I don't think it was clear.
replies(1): >>42542776 #
4. 1123581321 ◴[] No.42542776[source]
I got the same impression at first, but I reread and think he just needed to drop the first two paragraphs. I posted a response.
5. ◴[] No.42543116[source]
6. cbg0 ◴[] No.42546939[source]
Christmas ended a couple of days ago.
replies(1): >>42558273 #
7. ddtaylor ◴[] No.42558273{3}[source]
My reason for saying happy holidays is because I don't really have a specific thing I celebrate, I simply take vacation during all of December and don't like being in the cold. That's a holiday for me.