Most active commenters
  • neilv(4)

←back to thread

A 10-Year Battery for AirTag

(www.elevationlab.com)
672 points dmd | 17 comments | 18 Dec 24 18:17 UTC | HN request time: 1.136s | source | bottom
Show context
jmull ◴[19 Dec 24 19:42 UTC] No.42465013[source]▶
I know this is useful (for something), but I'm stuck on the plot holes in the motivating story...

Why didn't they replace the battery when the app complained?

How long would a thief really keep the AirTag anyway?

If the thief did keep the AirTag and you tracked them down, then what? A confrontation has a fairly high chance to have a worse result than losing some equipment. You could try to get the police to do it, but that's going to take more time, during which the thief is even more likely to ditch the AirTag.

Anyway, you're really swimming upstream trying to think of aigtags as an antitheft device. They're really for something lost, not stolen. Generally, they are specifically designed to not work well in adversarial situations.

replies(28): >>42465128 #>>42465202 #>>42465292 #>>42465303 #>>42465460 #>>42465554 #>>42465750 #>>42465858 #>>42466486 #>>42466585 #>>42466656 #>>42466744 #>>42466798 #>>42466905 #>>42467422 #>>42467653 #>>42467777 #>>42468238 #>>42468266 #>>42469043 #>>42469231 #>>42469724 #>>42470989 #>>42471280 #>>42472799 #>>42472809 #>>42477976 #>>42481533 #
joshuahaglund ◴[19 Dec 24 20:46 UTC] No.42465554[source]▶
I've retrieved stolen bikes, one because of an airtag. Showed up with a couple friends standing by but not trying to be intimidating. It's mostly about staying calm and telling the person this is mine, I'm taking it. They always say "no it's my friend's, you're gonna piss him off" or "I just bought this" or something. Maybe you offer some fraction of a "reward" to smooth it along and cut your losses. Don't try to start a fight and it generally goes OK. Also, try not to accuse them of stealing, they'll just get defensive. "It's someone else who is screwing us both, but this is mine sorry."
replies(3): >>42466818 #>>42466821 #>>42469423 #
nostromo ◴[19 Dec 24 23:27 UTC] No.42466818[source]▶
If it’s left anywhere in the open at anytime, you can repossess it legally as well. This happens with auto repossessions all the time. You don’t owe anyone an explanation as it’s yours - just take it if you can do so safely.
replies(3): >>42466899 #>>42469332 #>>42480492 #
mikeortman ◴[19 Dec 24 23:38 UTC] No.42466899[source]▶
Just be careful! In SOME jurisdictions, you can get in trouble for 'stealing' if you take back something that was stolen. Possession vs Ownership are 2 different things. For instance, the thief may have stolen something, sold it to someone who bought it in good-faith, and you take it back from that person, it's technically theft!

File a police report, go through the right channels. If you know its yours, call the police department non-emergency and explain the situation

replies(10): >>42466945 #>>42466970 #>>42467032 #>>42467388 #>>42468029 #>>42468376 #>>42468451 #>>42468731 #>>42470126 #>>42478230 #
neilv ◴[19 Dec 24 23:44 UTC] No.42466945[source]▶
This is the most useful advice: call the police non-emergency number, explain concisely, and ask them what to do.

A bunch of the other suggestions, here on HN Streetwise ProTips, can get self and/or friends beaten, stabbed, and/or arrested.

replies(4): >>42467001 #>>42467758 #>>42470782 #>>42472952 #
1. TylerE ◴[19 Dec 24 23:53 UTC] No.42467001[source]▶
No, THE most useful advice is not to take legal advice from cops.
replies(1): >>42467066 #
2. neilv ◴[20 Dec 24 00:04 UTC] No.42467066[source]▶
How do you think the police will give bad advice, if you call them up and ask what to do?
replies(4): >>42467252 #>>42467288 #>>42468032 #>>42468382 #
3. Kinrany ◴[20 Dec 24 00:44 UTC] No.42467252[source]▶
Depends on how well they do their job, it's not hard to imagine them saying "file a report" and then ignoring it.
4. extra88 ◴[20 Dec 24 00:52 UTC] No.42467288[source]▶
There are countless examples of police not knowing the law.

If you talk to them in person, it should be to get an idea of what they'll do, which may or may not have something to do with what's legal.

If you want legal advice, ask a lawyer with experience in the relevant area.

replies(2): >>42467486 #>>42467557 #
5. neilv ◴[20 Dec 24 01:35 UTC] No.42467486{3}[source]▶
You don't want legal advice. You know where your stolen bike is, so you call the police. I think that's the usual process.

Probably they will verify that the bike is yours, and retrieve it, or they will say that they don't have the resources.

Are people imagining that the police will say that you can go take the bike, but then turn around and arrest you for theft?

Of course, if the police tell you "finders keepers; it's in the Constitution", then you can seek legal advice.

replies(2): >>42468038 #>>42470258 #
6. outworlder ◴[20 Dec 24 01:55 UTC] No.42467557{3}[source]▶
They aren't even required to know the law.
7. ldoughty ◴[20 Dec 24 03:30 UTC] No.42468032[source]▶
Ages ago when I tried calling the police...

"We cannot answer legal questions, please seek a lawyer for advise."

I don't do anything terribly interesting, so this was almost certainly not an issue actually worth paying $200 for a lawyer to answer.

8. sneak ◴[20 Dec 24 03:31 UTC] No.42468038{4}[source]▶
No. The police will offer you the option to come to the police station and fill out a report so you can get a police report number for your insurance claim. Nothing else will happen.

Police don’t usually investigate petty crimes.

9. chii ◴[20 Dec 24 04:52 UTC] No.42468382[source]▶
> How do you think the police will give bad advice

the police will give you any advice, good or bad. They're not legally responsible for anything they said to you, as long as they're not telling you to commit a crime (in which case, if they did they will deny it).

You can still call 'em up of course - but don't 100% just trust their words blindly.

replies(1): >>42476369 #
10. michaelt ◴[20 Dec 24 11:33 UTC] No.42470258{4}[source]▶
> Are people imagining that the police will say that you can go take the bike, but then turn around and arrest you for theft?

People are imagining the police will tell you that you can't steal it back, when legally you can.

After all, it's the police's job to keep the peace. And things are more peaceful if I'm not busting up thieves' hideouts all guns blazing like Rambo.

replies(2): >>42472827 #>>42473899 #
11. wat10000 ◴[20 Dec 24 17:12 UTC] No.42472827{5}[source]▶
I’m also imagining the police telling you that you can do something that is actually illegal, and then you get prosecuted for it. “The cops said it was ok” may not be an adequate defense.
replies(1): >>42476654 #
12. neilv ◴[20 Dec 24 19:09 UTC] No.42473899{5}[source]▶
That's a reasonable suspicion (though I think a lot of the contrarian comments are just people who want to complain about the police).

Working with that suspicion, especially given that this is HN, police saying "don't go steal it back" might still be very good advice, regardless of legal right.

For example (referring back to a scenario earlier in thread), I'm imagining a techbro crew, all jumping into one of their Teslas, and rolling up on misguided urban youth turf.

There's already a lot of misunderstanding and animosity, both ways, between stereotypes. And someone's attempt at "show of force" just escalated it. So, who will escalate the stupid further, and stab or draw a gun first.

13. toss1 ◴[21 Dec 24 00:02 UTC] No.42476369{3}[source]▶
At this point in the US, it seems we are far better off asking ChatGPT or Claude than the average police station.
14. TomatoCo ◴[21 Dec 24 01:00 UTC] No.42476654{6}[source]▶
A cop telling you it's okay to do something, and then getting arrested for it, might be one of the only times you can correctly claim entrapment.
replies(1): >>42476686 #
15. fragmede ◴[21 Dec 24 01:08 UTC] No.42476686{7}[source]▶
So all Jessie Pinkman's got to do is ask the under cover police if it's okay to sell them meth and then they can't be arrested for it?

Entrapment is reserved for the police going above and beyond, eg "sell me meth or I'll kill your dog" where it can be argued that the entrapped normally would not do the crime.

replies(2): >>42476815 #>>42484473 #
16. wat10000 ◴[21 Dec 24 01:35 UTC] No.42476815{8}[source]▶
Apparently there is “entrapment by estoppel” in which a government official tells you an act is legal when it isn’t. They have to be acting as a representative of the government, though; undercover cops wouldn’t count.

I still wouldn’t be very excited to try this defense in court.

17. Dylan16807 ◴[22 Dec 24 04:57 UTC] No.42484473{8}[source]▶
> So all Jessie Pinkman's got to do is ask the under cover police if it's okay to sell them meth and then they can't be arrested for it?

No, this is about on duty police in uniform saying it's okay.