←back to thread

556 points greenie_beans | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0.973s | source | bottom
1. ausbah ◴[] No.42466930[source]
i think there really needs to be a set of laws prohibiting marketplace providers like uber, amazon, and spotify from also offering their own products on the same platform
replies(2): >>42467009 #>>42467166 #
2. legitster ◴[] No.42467009[source]
Despite the headline, it's not actually Spotify creating the music, but third parties taking advantage of their playlist model.
replies(1): >>42471698 #
3. phonetic ◴[] No.42467166[source]
Just a question—not meant to sound rude or offensive in any way—but would you also apply this logic to supermarkets offering their own generic brands‽
replies(2): >>42467203 #>>42478954 #
4. ricardobeat ◴[] No.42467203[source]
Why not? That can be construed as abusing their 'monopoly' over shelf space and foot traffic, it's unfair competition that displaces other legitimate businesses.

Incidentally, in the Netherlands a lot of supermarkets stock a 'shared house brand' called Gwoon. Usually the cheapest option by far and decent quality. I don't know what they do to keep prices as low as actual house brands, but it seems possible.

replies(1): >>42468357 #
5. sureIy ◴[] No.42468357{3}[source]
> I don't know what they do

Common products are actually not that expensive if you don't have to pay leeches like marketing agencies and investors.

6. Miraltar ◴[] No.42471698[source]
> third parties taking advantage of their playlist model.

Not really, it's a collaboration since Spotify actively promotes these third parties because they cost less royalties

7. arnvald ◴[] No.42478954[source]
I’ve been thinking about it and if there had to be a common rule for all these cases, I would say “yes”.

However, if it was possible, I would set a threshold maybe based on an annual revenue. Let’s say I run a small board game store, where I sell games from other producers, but also my own games that I published. I’m a small entrepreneur, should I be prohibited from exposing my products more?

Amazon, Spotify and some supermarket chains have such a dominant position in some markets they can abuse their position, they should be under scrutiny, but not small retail companies that want to try to create something on their own