←back to thread

116 points williamsmj | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.223s | source
Show context
flimsypremise ◴[] No.42311078[source]
As someone who has built multiple custom macro film scanner setups, owns basically very consumer film scanner of note (including the Coolscan 9000 and the Minolta Scan Multi Pro), and is intimately familiar with the workings of various film scanners and science of digitizing film, I don't think this article provides particularly good advice.

Just for instance, the LS-2000 features in the post has an advertised optical resolution of 2700DPI, which means the absolute maximum megapixel resolution you can get out of that thing is a little over 10MP. Film scanners are notorious for overstating their optical resolution, which has nothing to do with the resolution of sensor used to digitize the image data and everything to do with the lens in the scanner. You can have a 200MP sensor scanning your film but if your lens can only resolve 1000DPI you will have a very high resolution image of a low resolution lens projection. It's maybe a little better than a flatbed and it features dust removal, but in the year of our lord 2024 the LS-2000 is not a good choice for scanning film.

As for his macro scanning setup, he appears to be using the digitaliza for film holding, which is a notoriously bad product with many known flaws. Negative supply makes a line of lower cost version of their very good film holders, and Valoi also offers an affordable system of components that I highly recommend. There is a ton of good information out there about macro scanning, and had the OP sought it out he could avoided his little adventure in retro computing.

replies(7): >>42311162 #>>42311993 #>>42313343 #>>42314308 #>>42315213 #>>42318287 #>>42318746 #
1. 10729287 ◴[] No.42315213[source]
Thank you very much for all those informations. I kind of agree. It's a nice retrocomputing adventure but that doesn't seem that efficient. But eh, we know process is very important for us film shooters, so if he enjoys, it's mission complete to me. I used to painfully scan bw negatives with Epson flat scanner 15 years ago and the experience was awful. I just bought an EASY35 from Valoi to dig backinto my films with a 70mm Macro from SIGMA on Lumix S5. So far it's very impressive. Focusing straight on the grain is a dream. Is it the setup you use now ?