←back to thread

172 points voytec | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.214s | source
Show context
schoen ◴[] No.42199984[source]
By the way, the original adage from John Gilmore ("The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it") was referring to a behavior of Usenet rather than of the Internet. In particular, if articles didn't reach a node by one path, the node would still accept that they were missing (according to Usenet routing rules) and accept those articles from a different path. Thus, one could not prevent Usenet messages or newsgroups from reaching most of Usenet merely by deleting or not forwarding them on a single node. Another way of putting this is that the connectivity of Usenet was (in general though not everywhere) a web rather than a tree, and the Usenet software didn't assume that messages had to be forwarded along some particular path, if another path was available.

As with Jon Postel's maxim (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robustness_principle) people have also subsequently applied this to human behavior, not just the behavior of particular software.

There were ultimately more technically sophisticated means of censorship available on Usenet that were somewhat more effective.

replies(5): >>42200116 #>>42200324 #>>42200469 #>>42201746 #>>42206802 #
UltraSane ◴[] No.42200116[source]
It turns out that flooding your own lies is far more effective than trying to censor information.
replies(6): >>42200825 #>>42202176 #>>42202649 #>>42204563 #>>42207817 #>>42210965 #
cylemons ◴[] No.42210965[source]
But the lies can go in any direction. So the winner becomes who can lie more convincingly
replies(2): >>42216846 #>>42218427 #
1. lfmunoz4 ◴[] No.42216846[source]
Think it is more subtle than that. Straight out lying back fires easily it is more of spinning the story, i.e, on January 6 did we have an insurrection or protest? You have to push the agenda of your side so you have to try to re-define words. What is the definition of insurrection and protest? Those definitions need to be twisted so it is more subtle. Another example is "I did not have sexual relationships with that women. Oh I thought oral isn't a sexual relationship, so I didn't lie"