←back to thread

317 points thunderbong | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.216s | source
Show context
kibwen ◴[] No.42203962[source]
Hyrum's Law is one of those observations that's certainly useful, but be careful not to fixate on it and draw the wrong conclusions. Consider that even the total runtime of a function is an observable property, which means that optimizing a function to make it faster is a breaking change (what if suddenly one of your queues clears too fast and triggers a deadlock??), despite the fact that 99.99999999% of your users would probably appreciate having code that runs faster for no effort on their part.

Therefore it's unavoidable that what constitutes a "breaking change" is a social contract, not a technical contract, because the alternative is that literally nothing is ever allowed to change. So as a library author, document what parts of your API are guaranteed not to change, be reasonable, and have empathy for your users. And as a library consumer, understand that making undocumented interfaces into load-bearing constructs is done at your own risk, and have empathy for the library authors.

replies(9): >>42204203 #>>42204851 #>>42205110 #>>42205152 #>>42206063 #>>42206661 #>>42207782 #>>42209267 #>>42216851 #
bluGill ◴[] No.42205152[source]
That used to be a problem in the 1980s. Thus PCs came with a turbo button to slow them down, and 8 bit computers went the entire decade without upgrading their speed even though faster CPUs were available. These days nearly everything runs on more than one CPU and so nobody relies on function runtime (other than is if fast enough). Even in embedded they have been burned by their one CPU going out of production and so try to avoid that dependency because it cannot be relied on anymore.
replies(3): >>42207038 #>>42210679 #>>42211902 #
1. thayne ◴[] No.42211902[source]
> nobody relies on function runtime

Maybe not intentionally.

But there have been several times where I've seen bugs where two tasks are done concurrently, but task A always takes longer than task B, then someone makes A faster, and that exposes some race condition or deadlock that only occurs if A completes before B.