←back to thread

190 points amichail | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.443s | source
Show context
giancarlostoro ◴[] No.42194385[source]
I really dont understand why we cannot just go back to chronological as a default. This is how I use X/Twitter, and anything else that lets me just go chronological.
replies(15): >>42194402 #>>42194408 #>>42194410 #>>42194418 #>>42194422 #>>42194433 #>>42194454 #>>42194457 #>>42194459 #>>42194481 #>>42194542 #>>42194599 #>>42194719 #>>42194795 #>>42194821 #
coldpie ◴[] No.42194418[source]
It's because the majority of users are being fed more content than they can consume, whether that's through a large count of follows or global search results or a discovery tab. In that case, you need some method by which to decide what subset of that content to show to the user. Chronological ("show me the latest 50") is one option, but is it the best, for however one defines "best"? The people running these things seem to think it is not the best, for however they define "best", so we see the various discovery algorithms and all their associated pros & cons.
replies(4): >>42194516 #>>42194822 #>>42194829 #>>42198436 #
johannes1234321 ◴[] No.42194516[source]
> majority of users are being fed more content than they can consume

That is a group of users.

Another group of users follows only few active others and therefore sees only little content, but the platforms wants to show them something new all the time, to keep the platform "relevant" (in order to show more ads)

This then of course ignore the fact that they probably purposely follow only few.

replies(2): >>42194639 #>>42194877 #
1. MadcapJake ◴[] No.42194639[source]
Clearly the service is not designed for people to only engage with a few folks, it's meant to be a zeitgeist firehose. If you're only following a few people it's like using a spreadsheet for tracking household frozen pizza inventory.
replies(2): >>42195068 #>>42195685 #
2. dpkonofa ◴[] No.42195068[source]
This is a spot-on, although incredibly weird, analogy for it. It only works if you use it. You get out what you put in.
3. yamazakiwi ◴[] No.42195685[source]
The tool might be more sophisticated than you need but following only a few people is totally fine and should not be overrun with algo content just to promote ad revenue to the platform owner. Maybe the people you want to follow are only on said platform so you are required to consume it that way.