←back to thread

Why I hate the index finger (1980)

(pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
255 points consumer451 | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.756s | source
Show context
DiggyJohnson ◴[] No.42184584[source]
Worth the read.

I am so worried that we as a society have lost the ability to write well, and risk losing the ability to recognize and appreciate good writing. Rote professional written communication skills are changing and diminishing. The written word is generally seen to be a burden. Anyways, bittersweet thoughts from a really funny article.

replies(7): >>42185100 #>>42185215 #>>42185926 #>>42187271 #>>42187701 #>>42189885 #>>42189964 #
codexb ◴[] No.42187701[source]
Up until recently, there always seemed to be a marked difference between the way people spoke vs how they conveyed thoughts in writing. These days, it often feels like most writing is just conversational and stream of consciousness and differs little from how many people speak.

It always makes me curious how we generally view the people of antiquity as speaking very eloquently and properly, but that's probably because we only have writings from their time, not recordings of how they actually spoke.

replies(2): >>42189842 #>>42194749 #
blharr ◴[] No.42189842[source]
I'm surprised you mention us not having recordings of the older times being why we thought people spoke eloquently. Even in old recorded audio and video, like old TV, it feels to me like people speak much more eloquently.
replies(1): >>42191641 #
1. jaggederest ◴[] No.42191641[source]
Go listen to some Teddy Roosevelt speeches, blown away by the clarity and fluency. Or the Cross of Gold audio snippets.
replies(1): >>42197583 #
2. codexb ◴[] No.42197583[source]
Prepared speeches don't really count; they're basically reading written prose. I'd be interested to hear actual conversations from Victorian times. I wonder if they are anything like how we write them in TV shows and movies.
replies(1): >>42197778 #
3. jaggederest ◴[] No.42197778[source]
Well, we do have recordings from that period, but it would be as out there as having a finetuned AI of your own writings these days so I don't know how natural it would have been.

Also, apparently TR used the manuscript much less than most speakers, delivering much of the actual wording impromptu and the general structure from the script, so he was actually pretty fluent off the cuff.