←back to thread

473 points Bostonian | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
insane_dreamer ◴[] No.42179137[source]
I clicked on the links of the articles linked to by the author as "egregious" examples of Helmuth's editorial bias, and they're both clearly labeled _OPINION_. (Opinion articles are not scientific articles because they are __opinion__.)

May need to choose some better examples if the author wants to support his point.

replies(4): >>42179278 #>>42179479 #>>42183053 #>>42183149 #
crackercrews ◴[] No.42179278[source]
Why does a scientific magazine have an Opinion section in the first place? Has it always? I would guess the number of Opinion pieces has gone up dramatically in the last decade.
replies(3): >>42179358 #>>42179367 #>>42183821 #
insane_dreamer ◴[] No.42183821[source]
> Why does a scientific magazine have an Opinion section in the first place?

Nature has an Opinion section. New Scientist does too. Most magazines do.

> I would guess the number of Opinion pieces has gone up dramatically in the last decade

Did you do any research on this or just throwing out random guesses?

replies(1): >>42184140 #
1. crackercrews ◴[] No.42184140[source]
> Did you do any research on this or just throwing out random guesses?

As I said, I said it was a guess. I tried chatgpt, but no help there. I was hoping that people here who are more regular SA readers than me would have a sense of this.

It is well-known that people do not discern reporting and opinion coverage. IMO this barrier is exacerbated in scientific publications, where science-like language is used throughout. It gives the sense that "science" is behind the opinion.

This may not sway science-savvy readers of the magazine, but when it is reported elsewhere ("Scientific American magazine says XYZ"), it surely misleads people. I'd rather science magazines stick to science, but that's just me.

replies(1): >>42194669 #
2. warmcompress ◴[] No.42194669[source]
> As I said, I said it was a guess. I tried chatgpt, but no help there.

"We've tried nothing and we're all out of ideas"