←back to thread

An Uncanny Moat

(www.boristhebrave.com)
34 points ibobev | 6 comments | | HN request time: 0.804s | source | bottom
1. munificent ◴[] No.42177775[source]
> Similarly, we’ll see the rise of junk personalities – fawning and two-dimensional, without presenting the same challenges as flawed real people. As less and less of our lives are spent talking to each other, we’ll stop maintaining the skill or patience to do so.

This is already happening. We just call them "influencers" or "YouTubers". These are still technically real people, but they're real people playing a sanitized character while appearing/claiming some degree of authenticity. They are actual photographed humans, but often wildly digitally retouched to be more beautiful than any actual person.

And people increasingly are replacing real relationships with parasocial relationships with these complete strangers. It's understandable: like junk food, it satisfies an immediate craving with no real effort on the part of the consumer. But long-term, it is deeply unhealthy.

replies(3): >>42179502 #>>42182168 #>>42185577 #
2. viraptor ◴[] No.42179502[source]
Or, existing for much longer than the yt personalities: Japanese idols. Unique but replaceable, idealised personas worshipped by lots of people. They're also the parasocial relationship magnets.
replies(1): >>42182599 #
3. 082349872349872 ◴[] No.42182168[source]
> real people playing a sanitized character

Or, kings, priests, etc.

They get good NPC lines too: I heard that when the Queen of England went shopping in some random high street, she was told by the cashier that she looked just like the Queen, to which she (presumably in cut-glass) replied, "How very reassuring".

Not sure I appreciate a recent demagogue (whose listeners sanitise instead of letting handlers do so?) counterexample to:

— You know what happens when politicians get into Number 10; they want to take their place on the world stage.

— People on stages are called actors. All they are required to do is look plausible, stay sober, and say the lines they're given in the right order.

— Some of them try to make up their own lines.

— They don't last long.

replies(1): >>42193708 #
4. theshrike79 ◴[] No.42182599[source]
Or the bands where the name stays the same and they rotate members regularly.
5. Melonotromo ◴[] No.42185577[source]
We call them unironically INFLUENCERS. Like isn't that the most disturbing fucked up mental cognitive dissonance ever?

Like do we just accept that they are called Influencers and completly ignore what this word actually means?

6. noduerme ◴[] No.42193708[source]
This put me in mind of a friend in hospital. When one is terminally ill, given care, they take on the role of the patient. The doctors play the doctors. It is sometimes possible to make up your own lines, but again, you don't last long.

Maybe this is more of the human condition, merely projected onto politicians (and/or subconsciously selected for in all popular actors as a way to temporarily offset or allay our own existential dread: There's nothing more satisfyingly life-affirming for an audience than watching the rise and fall of someone else).