←back to thread

316 points pabs3 | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.53s | source
Show context
loufe ◴[] No.42171647[source]
Every time I have a personal project and want to make a simple CAD drawing of a building or a simple model, as I would using AutoCAD at work, I go through the same song and dance. I look around at the options online, my jaw hangs open at the cost of any commercial CAD subscription/licence, then I get frustrated by a glaring lack of functionality or useability while trying some free/open source solution, and resort to a 30 day trial or MSPaint/paper.

Some of the comments already mention how blender's existence is predicated upon it filling a niche in certain senses, instead of trying to achieve feature parity with an entrenched giant. That makes sense, and it's unfortunate, as this space could use an open source option with Blender's polish. In my own industry, mining, I am certain some commercial interests would happily make their product an extension/plugin for a polished FreeCAD (or other), were it at that point.

replies(8): >>42172002 #>>42172087 #>>42172196 #>>42172360 #>>42173613 #>>42173675 #>>42178441 #>>42197081 #
KeplerBoy ◴[] No.42172087[source]
What's wrong with Solidworks for Makers?

50$ a year sound perfectly reasonable to me.

replies(4): >>42172162 #>>42172520 #>>42172707 #>>42174847 #
mech422 ◴[] No.42172707[source]
Alibre (1) seems pretty popular with makers (good cnc support?). Not OSS but its a one time $200 purchase - sorta surprising you can still buy software these days :-P Alibre is more of a professional tool like Fusion 360, so there is some learning curve.

1. https://www.alibre.com/

replies(2): >>42173189 #>>42174503 #
1. hahamrfunnyguy ◴[] No.42174503[source]
I second Alibre, I am using the pro version. I bought it in 2012, and I can't remember if I've paid for upgrades to keep it current since then.

I used it to design an injection mold and I am still using it for 3d printing projects. It's a capable program and on-par with SolidWorks or Inventor for basic modeling.

I haven't tried OnShape yet, but if I didn't have Alibre I'd probably look into that or another web-based program for new hobby projects. I like the idea of perpetual licenses but it's only perpetual for as long as it runs on your operating system.

replies(1): >>42174564 #
2. mech422 ◴[] No.42174564[source]
I just can't get into the web based ones...I don't know why but they all seem slow and clunky to me. One thing I didn't like about alibre is the lack of Linux (or Mac) version, as I plan on ditching MS once my win10 box is unusable - I have no interest in that new AI crap MS is adding.