←back to thread

514 points moonsword | 5 comments | | HN request time: 0.738s | source
Show context
thrdbndndn ◴[] No.42168908[source]
Two questions:

1. surely unconditionally rebooting locked iPhones every 3 days would cause issues in certain legit use cases?

2. If I read the article correctly, it reboots to re-enter "Before First Unlock" state for security. Why can't it just go into this state without rebooting?

Bonus question: my Android phone would ask for my passcode (can't unlock with fingerprint or face) if it thinks it might be left unattended (a few hours without moving etc.), just like after rebooting. Is it different from "Before First Unlock" state? (I understand Android's "Before First Unlock" state could be fundamentally different from iPhone's to begin with).

replies(7): >>42168981 #>>42169169 #>>42169203 #>>42169266 #>>42169304 #>>42170569 #>>42171458 #
Kwpolska ◴[] No.42170569[source]
What legit use case involves not touching your phone at all for 3 days?
replies(5): >>42170902 #>>42170909 #>>42171167 #>>42173387 #>>42175323 #
1. adastra22 ◴[] No.42170909[source]
Not a phone, but at my old apartment I used to have an iPad mounted on the wall. It was a dynamic weather display, Ring doorbell answerer, multimedia control, etc. Would suck if every 3 days I had to enter my passcode again.
replies(3): >>42170942 #>>42172496 #>>42172862 #
2. Shank ◴[] No.42170942[source]
I haven’t tested this, but I assume this wouldn’t occur if the device is fully unlocked and powered on. Most kiosk adjacent deployments are setup so that they never turn the screen off and remain unlocked.
3. grishka ◴[] No.42172496[source]
Looks like something that doesn't need to have a passcode on it in the first place.
replies(1): >>42175351 #
4. myflash13 ◴[] No.42172862[source]
iPad has a kiosk mode for these use cases.
5. layer8 ◴[] No.42175351[source]
I have something like this as well, connected to my Apple account for calendar and reminder access etc. I wouldn’t want every random guest to have access to that.