←back to thread

116 points wslh | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.418s | source
Show context
Simon_ORourke ◴[] No.42162689[source]
Not putting too fine a point on it, but Gandhi's non-violent resistance worked in the India of his time, because the British wanted both the labor and the natural resources, and killing all the former would simply have cost them.

In Gaza and Ukraine right now, the colonial powers simply want the territory, and are largely indifferent or are openly hostile to the continued physical existence of the people who live there.

replies(6): >>42162919 #>>42164064 #>>42165833 #>>42165946 #>>42166882 #>>42168613 #
1. tim333 ◴[] No.42165946[source]
The British have mostly been fairly easy going about letting go of their colonies. Wikipedia has a list of 65 countries that have gained independence from the United Kingdom and I can only think of a couple where much warfare went on (the US and Ireland). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_that_have_ga...
replies(1): >>42167557 #
2. runarberg ◴[] No.42167557[source]
Since the mid 1960s the UK has been largely on board with decolonization efforts (with some exceptions including the Chagos islands), but this ignores a large number or colonial warfare they fought to keep their colonies in the 1950s, and the very early 1960s.

For example it is not untrue to say that Yemen successfully fought the UK to gain independence (at least South Yemen). In Rhodesia (now Zambia and Zimbabwe) and Nyasaland (Malawi) calls for independence (by ANC, NAC, etc.) was met with crackdown by the white Rhodesian army (who ruled south Rhodesia post independence with apartheid). In Kenya the Mau Mau rebellion was brutally suppressed by the British Army, with over 35000 insurgents killed by British colonial forces. The Mau Mau lost, and Kenya peacefully gained independence a few years later.

Even though most former British colonies got their independence by voting in a pro-independence government who negotiated for independence between the mid 1960s and the 1980s, which the British peacefully accepted (with rare exceptions), the years prior, any independence prospects were definitely met with various tactics to prevent their success, including violent and armed colonial warfare.