←back to thread

221 points caspg | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
spaceman_2020 ◴[] No.42164682[source]
I have about 6 months of coding experience. All I really knew was how to build a basic MERN app

I’ve been using Sonnet 3.5 to code and I’ve managed to build multiple full fledged apps, including paid ones

Maybe they’re not perfect, but they work and I’ve had no complaints yet. They might not scale to become the next Facebook, but not everything has to scale

replies(10): >>42164691 #>>42164720 #>>42164779 #>>42164879 #>>42164981 #>>42165012 #>>42165044 #>>42165081 #>>42165381 #>>42165482 #
yodsanklai ◴[] No.42164720[source]
What do you do if your app has a bug that your LLM isn't able to fix? is your coding experience enough to fix it, or do you ship with bugs hoping customers won't mind?
replies(5): >>42164780 #>>42164781 #>>42164783 #>>42164943 #>>42165218 #
epolanski ◴[] No.42164780[source]
What's the point of this question?

Everybody ships nasty bugs in production that he himself might find impossible to debug, everybody.

Thus he will do the very same thing me, you or anybody else on this planet do, find a second pair of eyes, virtually or not, paying or not.

replies(4): >>42164797 #>>42164964 #>>42165010 #>>42166331 #
1. lucianbr ◴[] No.42164964[source]
Presumably what is possible for a person with 6 months of experience is rather limited.

The idea as I understand it is that he achieved apps that he would not be able to write by himself, with the help of AI. That means that it is possible to have bugs that would be reasonable to fix for someone who built the app using their own knowledge, but for the junior they may be too hard. This is a novel situation.

Just because everyone has problems sometimes does not mean problems are all the same, all the same difficulty. Like if I was building Starship, and I ran into some difficult problem, I would most likely give up, as I am way out of my league. I couldn't build a model rocket. I know nothing about rockets. My situation would not be the same as of any rocket engineer. All problems and all situations and all people are not the same, and they are not made the same by AI, despite claims to the contrary.

These simplifications/generalisations "we are all stochastic parrots" "we all make mistakes just like the llms make mistakes" "we all have bugs" "we all manage somehow" are absurd. Companies do not do interviews and promote some people and not others out of a sense of whimsy. Experience and knowledge matters. We are not all interchangable. If LLMs affect this somehow, it's to be looked at.

I can't believe LLMs or devs using LLMs cand suddenly do anything, without limitations. We are not all now equal to Linus and Carmack and such.