←back to thread

84 points onemind | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.408s | source
1. yakshaving_jgt ◴[] No.42164346[source]
“Are the first two paragraphs a blockquote? If so, it’s odd to see the author describe themselves as acclaimed in the third person”

— yakshaving_jgt, reputable HN commenter

replies(2): >>42164418 #>>42164635 #
2. treetalker ◴[] No.42164418[source]
They are styled as a block quotation, but only to set them off from the rest of the text. It appears that the editor added them as an overview to help the reader decide whether to continue and to more quickly grasp the overall point.
3. dahart ◴[] No.42164635[source]
Out of curiosity… why does the oddness depend on whether the paragraphs are blockquote? It would be less odd without the blockquote mark on the left? Are you certain that someone else didn’t write that sentence? And what’s odd about it? Even if he did write it, isn’t it fairly standard practice to for people to write their own introductions & accolades in third person? I’ve seen it a lot, and the point, for better or worse, is to make it sound like someone else wrote it. In many cases authors of books, articles, talks, etc. are expected to provide their own introduction, and it’s kinder than expecting someone else to to know your history or say nice things about you.