←back to thread

133 points kristianp | 6 comments | | HN request time: 0.799s | source | bottom
1. Timwi ◴[] No.42163651[source]
The article perpetuates the widespread misconception that dinosaurs are extinct. In reality, (some) dinosaurs survived and evolved into modern birds. Everything from penguins to ostriches, hummingbirds to albatrosses and woodpeckers to eagles is a dinosaur.

Science communication should do better and clear up this misunderstanding.

It would be so much cooler to say that the asteroid killed the pterosaurs. Not only is it factually correct, it also opens doors to more curiosity. Why do they say pterosaurs instead of dinosaurs? Turns out they are separate clades. The pterosaurs, plesiosaurs and mosasaurs are all extinct as best as we can tell. The dinosaurs are not.

replies(2): >>42163702 #>>42164465 #
2. bregma ◴[] No.42163702[source]
Dinosaurs are delicious. They taste like chicken.
replies(1): >>42164374 #
3. pier25 ◴[] No.42164374[source]
Proof we live in a simulation. Everything tastes like chicken!
4. jvanderbot ◴[] No.42164465[source]
This is fascinating. Although I'm having trouble mapping your comment onto this: https://opengeology.org/historicalgeology/case-studies/dinos...

What is the complete set and which are extinct?

replies(2): >>42169608 #>>42183119 #
5. addaon ◴[] No.42169608[source]
> What is the complete set and which are extinct?

That's as good a complete tree as you're likely to get, down to the class level. Some species in the class Aves survived, and progenitor species with Aves are still around today. There's no significant evidence of species in other classes of the clade Dinosauria surviving much past the impact boundary.

You can push this up one level to the clade Avemetatarsalia (including Pterosaurs along with Dinosaurs) and the statement above would still be true; but pushing it further to Archosauria would not be valid, because crocodilians survived (and survive) as well.

6. Timwi ◴[] No.42183119[source]
The diagram in your link only shows the dinosaurs, not the entire tree of animals alive at the time. Within that diagram, everything except Aves (which, incidentally, is the Latin word for birds) is believed to be extinct.

The article makes no mention of other clades that lived during the Cretaceous, such as the pterosaurs, or indeed the mammals. Just as birds are descendants of the few surviving dinosaurs, we are descendants of the few surviving mammals.