←back to thread

177 points signa11 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
kstrauser ◴[] No.42160831[source]
Rust was a pain in the ass until I stopped trying to write C code in it and started writing idiomatic Rust. I don’t know the author of this blog, but he mentions extensive C++ experience which makes me wonder if he’s trying to write C++ in Rust.

Maybe not! Maybe it’s truly just Rust being stubborn and difficult. However, it’s such an easy trap to fall into that I’ve gotta think it’s at least possible.

replies(3): >>42160844 #>>42161027 #>>42161181 #
Aurornis ◴[] No.42161181[source]
> Rust was a pain in the ass until I stopped trying to write C code in it and started writing idiomatic Rust.

This is the #1 problem I see with people trying to learn a new language (not just Rust).

I’ve watched enough people try to adopt different languages at companies over the years that I now lean pessimistic by default about people adopting new languages. Many times it’s not that they can’t learn the new language, it’s that they really like doing things the way they learned in another language and they don’t want to give up those patterns.

Some people like working in a certain language and there’s nothing wrong with that. The problems come when they try to learn a new language without giving up the old ways.

Like you, I’m getting similar vibes from the article. The author wants to write Rust, but the entire premise of the article is about not wanting to learn the rules of Rust.

replies(5): >>42161933 #>>42162613 #>>42163170 #>>42167602 #>>42170866 #
1. pansa2 ◴[] No.42163170[source]
> The problems come when they try to learn a new language without giving up the old ways

In Python, I frequently see the same problem from the other side. Instead of C/C++ programmers learning Rust and "not wanting to learn the rules of Rust", it's Java/C# programmers learning Python and not wanting to unlearn the rules of Java/C#. They write three times as much code as they need to - introducing full class hierarchies where a few duck-typed functions would do.