←back to thread

317 points laserduck | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
0xmarcin ◴[] No.42157319[source]
This is not my domain so my knowledge is limited, but I wonder if the chip designers have some sort of a standard library of ready to use components. Do you have to design e.g. ALU every time you design a new CPU or is there some standard component to use? I think having a proven components that can be glued on a higher level may be the key to productivity here.

Returning to LLMs. I think the problem here may be that there is simply not enough learning material for LLM. Verilog comparing to C is a niche with little documentation and even less open source code. If open hw were more popular I think LLMs could learn to write better Verilog code. Maybe the key is to persuade hardware companies to share their closed source code to teach LLM for the industry benefit?

replies(3): >>42157350 #>>42157368 #>>42157788 #
1. Filligree ◴[] No.42157350[source]
Or learning through self-play. Chip design sounds like an area where (this would be hard!) a sufficiently powerful simulator and/or FPGA could allow reinforcement learning to work.

Current LLMs can’t do it, but the assumption that that’s what YC meant seems wildly premature.