←back to thread

332 points vegasbrianc | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.216s | source
Show context
guywithahat ◴[] No.42142070[source]
The whole thing is a colossal waste too, it was a law written by people who don't understand tech for special interest groups who don't want to actually make things better.

If you don't want a website doing something on your computer, you start with the browser, not the website.

replies(6): >>42142140 #>>42142206 #>>42142213 #>>42142536 #>>42145217 #>>42146713 #
1. hnbad ◴[] No.42145217[source]
It's not about your computer, it's about your data. Tracking cookies are just one aspect. The GDPR is about consent and ownership of your personal data. It literally defines your rights with regard to your pesonal data.

The GDPR and ePrivacy directive aren't just about cookies. They limit what a company can do with your data in general, who can access it and how long. Cookie banners are just a downstream consequence of it and the reason they're bad is that most companies try to be clever and design them maliciously in ways to coerce you into "opting in" even though this makes them non-compliant.

If DPAs were serious about enforcing the law, every single website not giving at least equal visual weight to the "refuse all and continue" button (or hiding it behind other options or using individual "legitimate interest" toggle buttons to sneak in their partners despite the existence of the toggle button invalidating the claim of "legitimate interest") would be punished with the maximum fine because they have purposefully and maliciously violated the law.