←back to thread

New Apple security feature reboots iPhones after 3 days, researchers confirm

(techcrunch.com)
286 points joegibbs | 4 comments | 15 Nov 24 01:55 UTC | HN request time: 0.783s | source
Show context
EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK ◴[15 Nov 24 05:40 UTC] No.42144225[source]▶
Auto restart has existed in Samsung phones since Android 5 Lollipop, 10 years ago. Glad technological progress eventually makes its way to Apple.
replies(1): >>42144694 #
1. future10se ◴[15 Nov 24 07:38 UTC] No.42144694[source]▶
It doesn't do the same thing security-wise, though. It's more of a "performance manager" (i.e. the same reason you'd reboot an old Windows PC).

BFU (Before First Unlock, as described in the article) on an Android is pretty similar to an iPhone (data still locked down, notifs don't come in, apps not running). Only after you unlock the first time can apps start running and notifs come in. This is also the state where it's more vulnerable to attackers (cops or criminals).

I have both an iPhone and an Android (currently a Z Fold 5, so a recent model). My Fold 5 does this auto-reboot every week. When it does reboot, my usual background apps come up, and notifs work as usual.

This means that Android (or perhaps more accurately, OneUI — Samsung's custom stuff on top of Android) is not doing a "full" reboot, and thus isn't providing the same security benefits as Apple is by putting the phone in a "BFU" or "cold" state.

replies(1): >>42144751 #
2. realusername ◴[15 Nov 24 07:49 UTC] No.42144751[source]▶
I just tried on my S23+ and no, I don't get any app notification, I need to enter the pin code for that.
replies(2): >>42146830 #>>42170774 #
3. themaninthedark ◴[15 Nov 24 13:41 UTC] No.42146830[source]▶
My S22 Ultra also does not display notifications after reboot until after login with pin.
4. future10se ◴[18 Nov 24 08:43 UTC] No.42170774[source]▶
Are we talking about the same thing? If I reboot manually then I don't get notifications until I enter my pin. But if my phone does the auto-reboot I do get notifs as usual.

This screen: https://i.imgur.com/jRS7Ffx.png

If there is a setting somewhere I can toggle so I get a "full" reboot, I would appreciate someone pointing it out to me.