←back to thread

286 points joegibbs | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.21s | source
Show context
BenFranklin100 ◴[] No.42143614[source]
It annoys me to no end to listen to the Android/Google apologists claim that Apple does not care about security and privacy.
replies(3): >>42143715 #>>42144409 #>>42144882 #
1. xethos ◴[] No.42143715[source]
Presumably because they disagree about what should be kept private from whom, and whether the user should be allowed to be in control of the security of the hardware.

Apple will vouch for applications running on, for example, MacOS. They'll check the developer's account is still in good standing, and will prevent apps from launching without this check. Sometimes this (arguably) helps. Other times it hurts [0]. And while I disagree with the choices made, these are valid trade-offs.

Apple will tie things like the hardware for FaceID, to a specific phone, and require it be re-paired by an Apple authorized technician. Sometimes this is bad - just look at any Right to Repair thread. Sometimes this is good - Evil Maid attacks don't occur often, but it's easy enough (from Apple's POV) to block them that it would almost be irresponsible not to.

There is room for these discussions, but it's geared more towards how one views general-purpose computing devices, IMO, and can't really be answered in a flamewar-style "Apple is evil" type of environment.

[0] https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/12/21563092/apple-mac-apps-...