←back to thread

391 points JSeymourATL | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
bane ◴[] No.42137229[source]
I'm about a year into a mid-effort level job search. I work in a somewhat specialized technical field and am fairly senior (I think in FAANG-ese I'd be an maybe an L7 if I understand their levels correctly). So this means I'm looking for management, director, deputy CTO or CTO positions depending on the company. I have a track record making my company lots of money, and opening up new opportunities worth many multiples of that. So the deck is already stacked against me as most positions are for jr or mid engineers, but I have a proven track record of growing responsibilities and (in my market) fairly recognizable success stories.

The search has been absolutely atrocious. Unlike anything I've ever seen before in 30 years of working in tech.

* I used to be able to simply pull on my network and get a position within 2 or 3 tries. Total job hunt time, under a month.

* The last time I had to go through this was pre-COVID, and I used a mix of my network and cold applications (around 50). I only heard back from 2 of the cold submissions and my network pulled me in to where I am today. Total job hunt time, around 4 months.

* I'm almost exactly 1 year in now, over 700 applications, people in my network can't even get responses for referrals. I've made it to 4 interview funnels, including stupidly exhausting FAANGs, for positions ranging from CTO to consultant filling a contract slot. 2 solid offers, both at least 40-60% below my current market rate. One executive recruiter ghosted me after we started discussing Total Compensation Packages.

I even had a friend post a position at their company, using my resume as the hiring template. Then they personally referred me to that position. I never received a call, and they never received any candidates.

It feels like being personally blacklisted, but it's affecting everybody I know.

The furthest I've gotten has been by hunting down corporate and executive recruiters directly, but I've had two recruiters get laid off halfway through the matching process. One FAANG recruiter has even contacted me hoping I could help them find a position.

Something is broken somewhere. Companies are starving for talent, and talent is starving for companies. The online applications sites are clearly filtering out people, but there appears to be massive churn in the recruiting side as well.

/r/recruitinghell is very representative of things I've seen.

I did notice that hiring activity has picked up since the rollover of the FY. Several 6-7 month old applications stirred somebody to contact me in the last month or so with a "great fit" that turned out to have nothing to do with my skillset.

My story is finally drawing to a close however, I've just negotiated a good position at a new firm and am setting a start date.

replies(4): >>42137426 #>>42137478 #>>42137647 #>>42139137 #
mxuribe ◴[] No.42139137[source]
First of all, congrats on getting a new gig! With a few minor differences, your experience is similar to my own. So, clearly, you are not alone! I will note that one other blockage that you likely encountered but maybe didn't note or focus on which has hit me (in addition to other factors you cited): agism. I have been in the workforce for a little over 28 years, and 24 of those years has been in some sort of IT or digital or technical-related team...and most recently i have felt the tinge of agism ridiculously high - moreso while trying to get a job, but also in some (but not all) areas of my current dayjob. Its funny, when applying for jobs, and when speaking with some potential hiring managrers, HR, etc....you get the feeling from their questions...But when working with a team of any age, and you bring value to the team, then agism is not as much of a thing. There are times when one's aged wisdom is highly regarded and valued...and then other times - most especially during hiring processes - where it is considered a potential problem. Again, i'm so glad you got your new gig, but it sure is hell out there! :-)
replies(1): >>42142879 #
1. bane ◴[] No.42142879[source]
I think you are right about the ageism. The company I'm moving to...I was interviewed by a group of people who are all about my age or older. They couldn't move fast enough to get the process moving, and skipped some of their hiring process to do so.

But the others, it's diabolically schizophrenic. And the problem I really have is the time wasted by all parties. Here's my specific experiences over the last year.

There was a small/med company that had an executive recruiter work very hard to recruit me. When I finally got around to meeting the leadership team, I was pretty easily the oldest among the team. By this point I had been through multiple rounds of phone and video interviews, had my background screened, references interviewed, writing samples reviewed, public speaking sample videos, compensation negotiated, everybody had already exchanged linkedin invites with me. It felt like I was basically meeting them to do a "vibe" check and set my start date. They passed, said I was "too technical" for the CTO role of this engineering company with a mandate to grow their technical business in an area I have high competency and a proven growth track record. I haven't written a line of code in anger in probably 6 years at this point.

Another one, a FAANG, specifically reached out to me to run a new office they were standing up, with a focus on growing talent. The job was almost exactly what a description of my last decade of employment has been (from that perspective). I did the personality and technical assessments and sample writing exercises followed by multiple rounds of multiple hour exhausting interviews. By the end of each of them, my interviewers were chit chatting with me about getting beers together in a couple weeks. Their go/no-go guy specifically signed off to hire me and told my recruiter to have me reach out to him when I started. Compensation was totally lined-up. Start dates were discussed. Pass, but with a strong referral to another part of the company in an area I have absolutely no competency. Easily over 100 person-hours were wasted on this exercise over two months.

I had a Googler I previously worked with specifically scout out an open position I would be good that had been open for a while, and sent my resume to their recruiter. Recruiter called me and had me take their "are you googly enough for us?" personality test. Then called back and said they were interested in talking to me for an entirely different position I have absolutely no background in. When I mentioned the referral and the specific position, the recruiter had no idea what I was talking about and said they'd get back to me. That was three months ago. I've interviewed with Google three or four times in the last ten years and to be honest, I don't think I would go there even with an offer just based on how bad the process is and honestly what they've turned into as a company.

A recruiter scouted me and put me in touch with a team at Microsoft looking for somebody like me. They didn't like me for that job, but did start me on another two openings. Did 3 or 4 rounds of interviews for both, was obviously not a good fit for one. For the other it went smashing, two of the interviewers in one of the jobs said they wished I could be their new boss. Then their boss was the final interview and passed before the call was over and was clear to let me know it. The recruiter disappeared right after the second round of interviews, and I found out they had been downsized along with one of the offices I had interviewed for. That recruiter reached out to me a month later and asked if I had any open positions for recruiters as they'd now entered into this hiring hellscape and couldn't get callbacks.

Through my network I did get an offer to start at a top-5 consulting company in my industry. They basically threw the offer at me to get me in the door. But it was very low, with no "package" in the package. So I passed.

I know it's not my resume, it's been spit polished by four recruiters, or my experience. My industry reputation is solid and even fairly well known in a couple circles. I'm almost a word for word match for some of these openings, my network is actively trying to pull me in, and these companies are reaching out to me so I know I'm good there.

For a year I've come home every night, search for open positions, and spend a couple hours applying. My only saving grace is that I'm actually in a good, very solid position right now, so there's no rush.

Only one company has ever really gotten back to me on a blind application and it's the one I'm going to.

The market is absolute hell.

replies(1): >>42145588 #
2. mxuribe ◴[] No.42145588[source]
Holy smokes, what a series of experiences! The things they put you through are ridiculous! And, the worse thing is that i'm sure any of those companies would have expected unbridled loyalty even after all that...which, i don't know about you, but i'm quite empty on giving any firm (even my current one) as much loyalty as i used to. Well, congrats again on the new role you got, and whew what a journey its been for you! Take care!
replies(1): >>42153832 #
3. bane ◴[] No.42153832[source]
You as well, and good luck! The right job is out there. Don't settle if you don't have to. And if you do, don't stop the search.