←back to thread

283 points IdealeZahlen | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.208s | source
Show context
non- ◴[] No.42139412[source]
One thing I've always struggled with Math is keeping track of symbols I don't know the name of yet.

Googling for "Math squiggle that looks like a cursive P" is not a very elegant or convenient way of learning new symbol names.

I wish every proof or equation came with a little table that gave the English pronunciation and some context for each symbol used.

It would make it a lot easier to look up tutorials & ask questions.

replies(24): >>42139503 #>>42139508 #>>42139524 #>>42139550 #>>42139564 #>>42139813 #>>42140054 #>>42140141 #>>42140285 #>>42140537 #>>42140722 #>>42140731 #>>42140919 #>>42141247 #>>42141746 #>>42141968 #>>42142338 #>>42143308 #>>42145853 #>>42147470 #>>42148120 #>>42148896 #>>42148973 #>>42149956 #
madcaptenor ◴[] No.42139813[source]
I have seen math textbooks that have a "table of symbols" or similar, by the table of contents or the index. It's really helpful. Also nice to have - a "map of the book" (I don't know a better name for this) which indicates graphically which sections of the book depend on which other sections. "Dependency graph", maybe?
replies(1): >>42140082 #
QuercusMax ◴[] No.42140082[source]
I wish music books would do this too - I've been self-teaching myself a little classical guitar, and some of the scores I'm reading have various symbols that have taken me quite a while to figure out. I eventually determined that a bold III means to play in third position in some books, but these things aren't consistent between publishers.
replies(1): >>42142277 #
dhosek ◴[] No.42142277[source]
Classical music is relatively standardized. Roman numerals to indicate position are standard practice for all string instruments (I remember learning this as a beginning bass player as a kid). You will sometimes see Roman numerals used as a means of identifying chords relative to the tonic of the current key, but that’s uncommon and the notation is a bit different than the position notation in how it’s placed on the staff (if it even appears on the staff and not in a harmonic analysis).¹ I’ve not seen the upper- and lower-case distinction in roman numeral notation I learned somewhere which uses cases to distinguish between major and minor in any classical music harmonization texts, but I may have just paid insufficient attention.

1. I have a vague notion that it might show up in figured bass once in a great while, but I could be wrong.

replies(2): >>42142353 #>>42143448 #
1. madcaptenor ◴[] No.42142353[source]
This all seems right to me. As for your figured bass comment, you could have something like iii^6_4 for an e minor chord with the B in the bass, when the key is C major. But if you were writing it next to the staff you wouldn’t need to write the iii - it’s implied by the bass note and the figures, and classically figured bass writes the minimum it has to, for example just 6 instead of 63 for a first-inversion triad.