←back to thread

162 points Aissen | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.478s | source
Show context
alexey-salmin ◴[] No.42130555[source]
> I have seen many fans, in the face of being told the reason for these changes, say that it doesn’t matter because they aren’t personally epileptic. This is, as you might understand, incredibly personally frustrating, and yes, very ableist. In saying this, these fans claim that disabled people do not have a right to feel safe when watching their favorite series, and that their wellbeing doesn’t matter in comparison to a few brighter shots of teenagers using their magic powers to punch each other.

I don't get it. Why is it bad wanting to see the unsafe version for yourself?

> Over 2500 fans signed a change.org petition asking Crunchyroll to take down this edited, safe, version of the series and instead upload an unedited version that was true to the original vision—even if it had the potential to cause seizures.

That's not how I read the petition in question. People are asking to get access to the original that they know exist. I can't find a paragraph that demands deletion of the edited safe version.

>> As fans, we implore Crunchyroll to try to acquire an uncut version of the simulcast as we are paying good money each month for the services they provide.

replies(9): >>42130678 #>>42131020 #>>42131144 #>>42132281 #>>42132368 #>>42132813 #>>42132923 #>>42132960 #>>42135783 #
1. Uehreka ◴[] No.42132368[source]
If they just want to see the unedited version, it feels lazy to demand that CrunchyRoll track down and host the episode when (in the time it takes to read the petition) you can just do some Googling and find it. Right now anyone who wants to see it can track it down (and the Streisand Effect will ensure that remains the case) but it isn’t so easy to find that someone would stumble across it by accident. Why change that status quo?

This kind of feels like a troll petition, especially with that weird invocation of “we are paying good money each month for the services they provide”. People often tack that sentence on to something when it’s clear that what they’re asking for isn’t self-evidently necessary.

replies(2): >>42132675 #>>42132873 #
2. notpushkin ◴[] No.42132675[source]
It's not necessary, but it is nice to have. IMO demanding the original version would be inappropriate, but you can ask for it.
3. denkmoon ◴[] No.42132873[source]
You can simply "just do some Googling and find it" for literally everything on CrunchyRoll. That's called piracy though, and there are various reasons why people buy a crunchyroll subscription instead of doing that.

Seems quite a reasonable request to me.

replies(1): >>42157036 #
4. fennecbutt ◴[] No.42157036[source]
I cancelled my c roll sub because they don't have anything on there. None of the older classic anime, only the newer ones which I'm not really interested in.

Every time I look up an older one (2000s) to watch it, they don't have it. So no wonder people pirate it all.