←back to thread

45 points gmays | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.406s | source
Show context
sdenton4 ◴[] No.41916311[source]
Sure, there's no 'digital savior' (as the article puts it) - these are tools which can often help triage the great majority of 'boring' cases, focusing human attention where it is most-needed. In that sense, they are multipliers for the effectiveness of human labor, which is exactly what you want out of any given technology.
replies(1): >>41916502 #
1. kevingadd ◴[] No.41916502[source]
It gets tricky though. Let's say that 90% of your 'bad posts' are just basic stuff AI can handle, like insults or spam.

You deploy an AI to moderate, and it lets you cut your moderation workforce by 80%. Maybe you're a generous person, so you cut by 50% instead and the remaining moderators aren't as overworked anymore. (Nobody's going to actually do this, but hey, let's be idealistic.)

Costs are down, things are more efficient. Great! But there's a little problem:

Before, 90% of the posts your moderators looked at were mundane stuff. They'd stare at it for a moment, evaluate the context, and go 'yeah this is a death threat, suspend account.'

Now all the moderators see is stuff that got past the AI or is hard to classify. Dead bodies, CSAM, racist dogwhistle screeds, or the kind of mentally unhinged multi-paragraph angry rants that get an account shadowbanned on places like HN. Efficiency turns the moderator's job from 'fairly easy with occasional moments of true horror' into 'a nonstop parade of humanity's worst impulses, in front of my face, 40 hours a week'.

replies(2): >>41916586 #>>41916999 #
2. AIorNot ◴[] No.41916586[source]
I don't think the articles point is about auto-moderation of harmful content

instead its about being empathetic of the human suffering this work entails and finding ways to treat their contractors as humans instead of 'far off resources'

outsourcing this dirty and dingy work to African countries in this way without caring for the 'contractors' is a recipe for de-humanization of people..

https://www.sama.com/our-team

their team page is funny reminder of classism and racial disparity in the world white people at the top and black people at the bottom.. lol I know they aren't racially driven and there is real economic value for the contractors as jobs but our current hyper-capitalistic global system is mostly setup to exploit offshore people instead of elevate them

the world is what it is..

3. xtreme ◴[] No.41916999[source]
Your conclusion does not follow from your premise. AI moderation should easily catch the worst offenders and the most obvious ones. The examples you gave easily stand out from non-offensive content and are easy to catch with high confidence. So, human moderators will have to look at where AI has low confidence classifying the content. In fact, AI will reduce the likelihood of human moderators ever seeing traumatic content.