←back to thread

243 points rcarmo | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.737s | source
Show context
purpleblue ◴[] No.41909618[source]
The sheer unadulterated racism from the past is horrifying and sickening. Sure, we still have work to do, but I'm glad we've come so far in the last few decades.
replies(3): >>41911077 #>>41911200 #>>41914318 #
Spooky23 ◴[] No.41911077[source]
It’s still here. We dress it up as voter ID or something similar.
replies(6): >>41911460 #>>41911500 #>>41911651 #>>41912445 #>>41914877 #>>41914967 #
1. consteval ◴[] No.41914076[source]
From a statistical standpoint, there are proportionally less black people with ID than other racial groups.

It's not a matter of capability, it's purely a factual matter. It's not up for debate black Americans would be disproportionality affected, and as such you can easily argue the policy has racist intentions. What some black Americans say, and what some politicians say, does not matter.

2. llamaimperative ◴[] No.41914086[source]
Assuming that you’re sharing this in good faith, the claim “it’s difficult for black folks to get identification” is a compressed way of saying “ease and necessity of accessing civil services like DMVs is not evenly distributed across the country e.g. very GOOD accessible civil services in Harlem, Manhattan and NOT very accessible civil services in rural Appalachia, and the unevenness tends to correlate with other forms of inequality in our society such as along rich/poor and white/black lines, meaning some types of voter ID laws create systematic bias in who is able to exercise their constitutional right to vote, and given that it is effectively impossible to make any impact in any election via voter fraud even without voter ID laws, the mass disenfranchisement of a non-random sampling of Americans is not worth the upside.”

Hope that helps!

replies(1): >>41915400 #
3. tbyehl ◴[] No.41915084[source]
Weird how young-ish people in a particularly dense urban setting with plentiful public transit and many DMV offices to choose from — TIL: several exclusively for AAA members — may have a different lived experience than, say, older people in a rural county roughly half the size of Rhode Island with no public transit and a single DMV office.

Tho the county I refer to barely has any black residents so there couldn't possibly be any racial motivations. Just like the nearby restaurant plastered with a bunch of "rules" in giant lettering on the exterior, such as "No sagging pants", isn't owned by a racist. /s

Ruby Bridges is still alive and younger than our last president.