←back to thread

93 points elsewhen | 7 comments | | HN request time: 1.028s | source | bottom
1. SamuelAdams ◴[] No.41910639[source]
> there’ll be detailed comparisons between the AirPods Pro 2 and existing OTC devices in the near future once iOS 18.1 is widely available.

As someone with a diagnosed, severe hearing loss, I wonder how these compare to prescription hearing aids. I currently wear a pair of Phonak hearing aids and am looking to replace them, but I wonder if spending 5-6k on another pair is worth it versus the OTC or Apple AirPod options that exist today.

replies(2): >>41910681 #>>41910741 #
2. an_d_rew ◴[] No.41910681[source]
My experience is that they serve different purposes.

I have a very nice and expensive set of ReSound hearing aids and they're fabulous at what they do, which is focus on speech and kind of on music if I set them for that.

They're also unobtrusive and easily last 18-20 hours on a charge. I forget I'm wearing them, and nobody notices that I have them.

My AirPods I use primarily for running and listening to music because they just sound unbelievably better, and they're probably fine for a concert although I haven't done that with them. But I think for long-term use every day all day it wouldn't be that comfortable or unobtrusive.

Would love to hear the experience of somebody who's trying it, though!

replies(2): >>41910813 #>>41910847 #
3. ilt ◴[] No.41910741[source]
If you have severe and above hearing loss, these won’t help much. This is what I have gotten to know from lot of forums. They do work well for my moderate-to-severe hearing loss. Been using for around 7 months now.
replies(1): >>41911013 #
4. nomel ◴[] No.41910813[source]
Looking at the web, they’re also over $4500. I think the people who will most appreciate the AirPods are the ones that can now afford to put something in their ear to help their hearing.
5. wenc ◴[] No.41910847[source]
I don't have hearing loss, but I wear 2 pairs of AirPods Pro 2 over the course of a 10 hour day. The reason I have 2 pairs is because 1 pair only gets 5-6 hours of battery life, and I need to swap them while they recharge in the case.

Comfort? To me, very comfortable. I just leave them in there with Active Noise Canceling on all the time.

I may be showing my age, but if you remember "Get Smart", AirPods Pro 2 are like a Cone of Silence -- except they actually work.

6. an_d_rew ◴[] No.41911013[source]
Yes the problem with severe hearing loss is that hearing aids simply cannot compensate for what is no longer there.

Hearing aids are actually a a lot more complicated than just boosting frequencies. At the very simplest, these days they are wide/multi band compressors that try to balance discomfort with natural hearing, generally focusing on speech intelligibility since that is by far the most important target.

If you have severe hearing loss I would strongly recommend putting yourself in the care of a professional. Costco is a great source of probably the lowest cost versus highest quality hearing aids these days... but the reason I say "professional" is because there are so many kinds of hearing loss and they all affect your perception markedly differently.

It's a lot more than just "missing some sensitivity at some frequencies".

replies(1): >>41911028 #
7. ilt ◴[] No.41911028{3}[source]
I know what you mean. I am in India. Hearing aids are exorbitantly priced here and there is no Costco. I will definitely go for more professional ones once I can afford them, and not just buying them, but losing them too.