←back to thread

197 points LorenDB | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0.889s | source | bottom
1. exabrial ◴[] No.41908556[source]
If they hadn't abused this feature, they wouldn't be in this situation. I can totally understand carrier-locking a phone until the loan is paid off. But that's not what they used it for and now they're suffering hilarious regulatory attention.

tsk tsk. I almost feel bad for them.

replies(1): >>41908703 #
2. xahrepap ◴[] No.41908703[source]
I was already an existing TMobile customer. I bought myself and my wife an iPhone 11 in cash when the phones were brand new. Never had a contract. Already had an LTE plan, didn't change that plan at all. Just bought two new phones from TMobile and had them slap the sims in.

Fast forward to a couple months ago, I happened to notice while browsing my TMobile account that my phone was being reported as "Carrier Locked" with subtext that said "This phone is not eligible to be unlocked". Not my wife's though, hers was listed as "Unlocked". It took over a month of being yanked around by TMobile reps telling me they had to "escalate but the issue will be fixed within a week". It never was.

They would ask me why I wanted it unlocked. I would just respond something respectful but firm along the lines of "Because it's my phone. I paid for it. You have no business locking my device"

The way I see it, it was either theft or false advertising, plain and simple. Either they stole the phone from me after I bought it. Or, they sold me a device as unlocked but never realized that promise. It should have NEVER been locked. It makes me mad just thinking about it. I don't understand why a carrier even has the power to remotely lock a phone that was never theirs to lock in the first place.

This is all to say: I agree with your observation. They deserve heavy handed regulation because they have proven they will abuse any inch you give them.

replies(3): >>41908810 #>>41909011 #>>41909217 #
3. triyambakam ◴[] No.41908810[source]
Do you mean that your phone remains locked?
replies(1): >>41908900 #
4. xahrepap ◴[] No.41908900{3}[source]
Ah, sorry. I forgot part of the story :)

No, after over a month of them saying "it'll take a week for it after I escalate" and then me calling a week later and starting the whole conversation over, one day it finally was unlocked. And I moved to a new carrier.

5. fourteenfour ◴[] No.41909011[source]
I tried to get T-Mobile to unlock my far out of contract iphone 6s a few years ago, which should be super simple. The first time I talked to a rep and confirming everything they said it should show as unlocked in a few days. A month later and it wasn't unlocked. I called again and went through the same steps with another rep, they said it would be unlocked for sure this time. Nope. Luckily my friend gave me their old unlocked iPhone and I switched carriers. That 6s is still locked, T-mobile is scummy.
6. irunmyownemail ◴[] No.41909217[source]
This made me nervous, I used their web site under accounts check unlock status. It shows unknown for ours. We bought our Android phones on Amazon. I guess that's why the status shows as unknown for ours.
replies(1): >>41909834 #
7. theschmed ◴[] No.41909834{3}[source]
Isn’t the phone itself the best place to check, rather than your carrier’s website?

It’ll vary per manufacturer exactly where to find the info on the phone, but it’ll be reliable. You can also use an IMEI checker website, although some of those are ridden with ads and upsells.