←back to thread

366 points virtualwhys | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
fweimer ◴[] No.41897588[source]
The big advantage is that you do not need any extra space if your workload mostly consists of INSERTs (followed by table drops). And it's generally unnecessary to split up insertion transactions because there is no size limit as such (neither on the generated data or the total count of rows changed). There is a limit on statements in a transaction, but you can sidestep that by using COPY FROM if you do not have to switch tables too frequently. From a DBA point of view, there is no need to manage a rollback/undo space separately from table storage.

Every application is a bit different, but it's not that the PostgreSQL design is a loser in all regards. It's not like bubble sort.

replies(4): >>41897732 #>>41902493 #>>41904079 #>>41905601 #
indulona ◴[] No.41897732[source]
> but it's not that the PostgreSQL design is a loser in all regards

the article literally says that pg's mvcc design is from the 90s and no one does it like that any more. that is technology that is outdated by over 30 years. i'd say it does not make it a loser in all regards, but in the most important aspects.

replies(4): >>41898162 #>>41898235 #>>41898303 #>>41902986 #
mikeocool ◴[] No.41898235[source]
When it comes to your data store, some people might consider using technology that’s been reliably used in production by many organizations for 30 years a feature not a bug.

I’d prefer not to be the first person running up against a limit or discovering a bug in my DB software.

replies(2): >>41898511 #>>41908322 #
1. simne ◴[] No.41908322[source]
Tell this to developers of Ariane 5, who used old proven software from Ariane 4.

Many people consider this most expensive bug in history, when on first flight of Ariane 5, it enters speed range, which was hard prohibited in Ariane 4 software and caused software exception and then 1 billion crashed.

Honesty, they could re-check all ranges, but they decided, it would cost like write new software, so to save money, was made decision to just use old software, without additional checks.